兩會熱詞 中文專題
    NewsGovt ReformKey ReportsPress ConferencesIn the LimelightPanel DiscussionNewsmakerEditorialBackgrounderLeadershipNew FacesForumVideoPhoto
    Substance without all the sparks
    By Jules Quartly (China Daily)
    Updated: 2008-03-18 07:23

    From this outsider's perspective looking in, the annual sessions of China's top legislature and political advisory body appear to be remarkably harmonious.

    By the end the first session of the 11th CPPCC National Committee, 4,772 proposals had been raised, covering agriculture, healthcare, education, employment, social security, housing, environmental protection and food and drug policies.

    But among the suggestions and polite discussion there seems to have been little time left to argue. There was none of the obvious cut-and-thrust that characterizes politics elsewhere.

    Legislative sessions in the United States, much of Europe and in many Asian countries, for example, often feature a lot of grandstanding, with politicians arguing their cases and being shot down by members of the political opposition. Prime minister's question time in England is a bit like bear baiting. Politicians wait their turn to savage the leader and when they smell blood jump in for the kill with a rhetorical lunge.

    This was termed "adversary politics" by the scholar S. E. Finer and characterized as "a stand-up fight between two adversaries for the favor of the lookers-on".

    This raises the question: When does the arguing happen? Before the NPC-CPPCC? Or after? Is Chinese politics really so harmonious? As an outsider, I thought it prudent to ask the insiders, journalists who know how the system works.

    One reporter who is covering the sessions said there were, in fact, differences between delegates and their disagreements were public. She pointed to the case of the "symbolic city" planned in the hometown of Confucius in Shandong province.

    The 300-sq-km city is intended to revive traditional values and will be a site for national ceremonies. It is projected to cost about 30 billion yuan ($4.2 billion).

    Even so, this did not deter CPPCC member and president of the Anhui Dramatists' Association Hou Lu from speaking up. She said she was a taxpayer and didn't want her money thrown away on a white elephant, then wrote a counter-proposal and started a petition against it.

    Another colleague said NPC deputies were encouraged to be more outspoken. A cursory look at our own coverage reveals a diversity of opinions. For instance, there was a plethora of suggestions on how to improve healthcare.

    These ideas will be forwarded, along with the other proposals, to standing committees for further consideration and possible implementation. Presumably there will be counter proposals and nitpicking over the details. This is "democratic centralism" in action, a tenet of the Constitution.

    My feeling is that openness and transparency are important, if only for the reason that we tend to show what we are proud of and hide what we are ashamed of. It is also an important mechanism to hold people accountable.

    More people generally have better ideas and make better decisions than just one person. This is why public input in the political process is necessary.

    Adversarial politics and hissy fits add spice for the media, sells papers and drives up clicks on the Internet. But eventually the public tires of it, hence the apathy of many voters in established democracies.

    The model here is socialist political democracy, which entails people making proposals, discussion and collective decisions so the majority is respected while the minority is protected. In action, it appears more consensual than argumentative.

    The author is a writer / copy editor with China Daily

    (China Daily 03/18/2008 page7)



    Copyright 1995-2008. All rights reserved. The content (including but not limited to text, photo, multimedia information, etc) published in this site belongs to China Daily Information Co (CDIC). Without written authorization from CDIC, such content shall not be republished or used in any form.
    久久久久久国产精品无码下载 | 国产精品99无码一区二区| 久久久噜噜噜久久中文福利 | 国产激情无码一区二区app| 免费无码国产在线观国内自拍中文字幕 | 亚洲日韩激情无码一区| 亚洲中文字幕日产乱码高清app | 成人午夜福利免费专区无码| 亚洲色无码一区二区三区| 狠狠精品干练久久久无码中文字幕| 18禁黄无码高潮喷水乱伦| 亚洲Aⅴ无码专区在线观看q| 在线看片福利无码网址| 欧美日韩中文在线| 中文字幕一区二区人妻| 黑人无码精品又粗又大又长 | 亚洲AV日韩AV永久无码绿巨人| 日韩免费在线中文字幕| 中文人妻av高清一区二区| 国产精品无码免费播放| 久久久久亚洲AV无码专区体验| 中文人妻无码一区二区三区| 天堂在线观看中文字幕| 伊人热人久久中文字幕| 日韩久久久久久中文人妻| 亚洲Av无码乱码在线znlu| Aⅴ精品无码无卡在线观看| 日韩免费无码一区二区三区| 亚洲一区二区三区AV无码| 精品久久亚洲中文无码| 少妇性饥渴无码A区免费 | 无码人妻精品一区二区三区99仓本 | 无码H肉动漫在线观看| 午夜不卡无码中文字幕影院| 夜夜添无码试看一区二区三区| 亚洲AV无码一区二区三区牛牛| 日韩三级中文字幕| 国产成人无码AV麻豆| 亚洲熟妇无码另类久久久| 人妻无码中文久久久久专区| 国精无码欧精品亚洲一区|