Society

    ATM 'thief' wants compensation

    By Li Yingqing and Guo Anfei (China Daily)
    Updated: 2010-01-19 07:36
    Large Medium Small

    KUNMING: When He Peng set foot in Tongle Square of Luliang county, Yunnan province, at 2 am on Saturday, the 30-year-old felt like a stranger in his hometown.

    He was sentenced to life imprisonment in 2002 after withdrawing nearly 430,000 yuan ($63,000) from his bank's ATMs, which gave him money that was mistakenly put into his account by a bank clerk.

    He was set free at midnight on Saturday and given a second shot at life after Xu Ting, a young man in Guangzhou, capital of Guangdong province, who committed a similar crime, had his life sentence commuted to five years in 2008. In the aftermath, media coverage raised questions over the fairness of the judicial system.

    His lawyer also plans to seek State compensation for his incarceration.

    Related readings:
    ATM 'thief' wants compensation ATM swallows bank card, gets assaulted by duo
    ATM 'thief' wants compensation Daring crooks try to steal ATM machine
    ATM 'thief' wants compensation Woman uses credit card found in ATM and pays
    ATM 'thief' wants compensation Man locked in ATM booth wants compensation
    ATM 'thief' wants compensation Smooth operators steal woman's ATM card

    A freshman at Yunnan's provincial police academy in 2002, He Peng discovered 1 million yuan in his account at the Agriculture Bank of China at the ATM on March 2, 2001.

    After his first withdrawal attempt, He found the money was real and proceeded to draw several thousand yuan more, "thinking maybe some relatives had deposited the money for me", he was quoted in a Beijing News report as saying.

    The second day, he drew more from ATMs all over the provincial capital of Kunming. He took a total of 429,700 yuan. He then asked his mother to help declare the loss of his bank card.

    He was arrested on March 5, 2001, and jailed for stealing the money on July 12 that year.

    The man's plea of innocence was subsequently denied and the Yunnan Higher People's Court upheld the sentence.

    Appeals filed

    Many lawyers who offered to help He and his family members said they tried various means to file appeals for him.

    "We have spent almost all the savings of our family, more than 300,000 yuan, for our son's case," said He's mother Meng Xiaoyue.

    "We've been to Beijing 10 more times and we had to go to the city or the provincial capital almost three times a month."

    He's family filed a third and last appeal to the higher court in July last year and on Nov 18 the court made the order to ascertain the facts of He's first trial and changed his sentence to eight-and-a-half years in prison.

    "Thanks to those lawyers, law experts, journalists and the friends and relatives, my son's fate changed," He Jiangui, the man's father, said at a banquet on Saturday to welcome He home and thank supporters.

    "He (Peng) was imprisoned while he was only a student. Now he's a 30 year-old man. What I am concerned about most is his lack of social experience. I wish he could marry a good girl and live a peaceful and normal life," his father said.

    Yao Yongan, He's lawyer, maintains that He is innocent. He claims that it was a malfunction of the ATM machine that led to the case of Xu Ting in Guangzhou. However, He Peng's case was caused by the bank's mistake. He argues that the bank mistakenly deposited 1 million yuan into He's account, and that led to the consequences.

    Now, Yao said he would enter a plea of not guilty for He's crime. If he succeeds, He would apply for State compensation.

    Zhu Wei, a lawyer and PhD candidate of the law school of the Beijing-based Renmin University of China, who had hosted a series of seminars on He Peng's case, suggested that this case is quite different from the case of Xu Ting.

    Xu's case is one of larceny, while He's case leans toward a misappropriation offense. Under civil law, He's case is one of illegitimate gains caused by bank's fault. As such, the essence of He's case is said to be milder than Xu's.

    In an interview with the Kunming-based Metro Times, He Peng said he did wrong but that he is not guilty of the crime he was charged with.

    "I need to think about filing the appeal," He said, adding that he should re-enter society as soon as possible and support his debt-ridden family.

    The Xu Ting case

    Xu Ting, a 25-year-old native of Shanxi province, worked in Guangzhou, capital of Guangdong province, and withdrew 175,000 yuan through 171 ATM transactions in 2006 from his bank card that had only 170 yuan. Xu knew the machine was malfunctioning that day.

    Xu was sentenced to life imprisonment in the trial at the Guangzhou Intermediate People's Court on Nov 29, 2007.

    The case was extensively reported by the Guangzhou media and caused heated debate among legal circles.

    It later became an issue at the National People's Congress and Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference meetings.

    In March 31, 2008, the Guangzhou intermediate court changed Xu's life sentence to a fixed-term imprisonment of five years.

    无码无套少妇毛多18p| 最近中文字幕大全免费视频| 精品久久久久久中文字幕| 无码丰满少妇2在线观看| 欧美中文字幕在线视频| 人妻丰满熟妇无码区免费| 久久久无码精品亚洲日韩按摩| 中文字幕精品一区二区日本| 91嫩草国产在线无码观看| 国产丰满乱子伦无码专区| 人妻中文字幕乱人伦在线| 精品久久久久久无码人妻热| 水蜜桃av无码一区二区| 最近中文2019字幕第二页| 欧美日韩中文在线视免费观看| 日韩美无码五月天| 人妻aⅴ无码一区二区三区| 成人无码AV一区二区| 最近免费字幕中文大全视频| 亚洲中文字幕无码一区二区三区| 久久久久久久人妻无码中文字幕爆| 国产成人无码AV一区二区 | 免费无码av片在线观看| A狠狠久久蜜臀婷色中文网| 无码精品人妻一区| 国产精品无码久久久久| 十八禁无码免费网站| 亚洲国产精品无码专区| 亚洲精品无码专区在线在线播放| 中文字幕久久精品| 国产品无码一区二区三区在线| 日本中文一区二区三区亚洲| 中文字幕精品视频| A狠狠久久蜜臀婷色中文网| 亚洲第一中文字幕| 亚洲日本va午夜中文字幕一区| 亚洲中文字幕久久精品无码APP| 亚洲AV中文无码乱人伦在线观看| 中文字幕AV影片在线手机播放| 亚洲一区二区无码偷拍| 亚洲av午夜国产精品无码中文字|