Web Exclusive

    Google incident does not break WTO rules

    By Zheng Zhihai (chinadaily.com.cn)
    Updated: 2010-03-09 15:50
    Large Medium Small

    Some NGOs are reportedly accusing the Chinese government of being in breach of its WTO obligations in regulating Google China's search service and urged the Obama administration to take China to WTO to settle the dispute.

    Few details are available from news reports, but I would elaborate the case from the legal perspective and I believe that these accusations are groundless, as China's regulations on Google are within the confines of its domestic laws and accords with its promises to the WTO.

    Google always enjoys market access and national treatment in China

    As an Internet search provider, the services Google provides fall into the categories of "online information and data processing" and "online information and data searching", according to WTO rules and Chinese laws and regulations.

    China set clear restrictions on the above services in its promises when it was admitted into the WTO. To enjoy full national treatment, foreign companies must set up joint ventures in China and owns no more than 50 percent of the capital.

    Google China did exactly the same.

    Related readings:
    Google incident does not break WTO rules Microsoft CEO: Google merits regulatory scrutiny
    Google incident does not break WTO rules Google's business practices under fire in Europe
    Google incident does not break WTO rules China denies govt links to cyber attacks on Google

    Its subsidiary in Ireland set up a joint venture with Beijing Feixiangren Information Technology Ltd and registered under the same name of the Beijing company with each sharing 50 percent of the capital, providing services through www.google.cn.

    Since its entry into the Chinese market, Google has been enjoying rightful market access and national treatment. Its market share in China jumped from 13 percent at the beginning of 2006 to around 36 percent in the fourth quarter of 2009.

    Opening market does not mean waiving the right to govern

    However, market access and national treatment are, in fact, not major bones of contention this time. What Google challenges is China's lawful right to govern its Internet, specifically, the right to censor the Internet.

    The WTO rules state clearly that the governments of member states have lawful right of supervision, including censoring Internet content. According to the General Agreement on Trade in Services, measures like Internet censorship that are universally applicable to service providers can be applied as long as they are reasonable, impartial and fair. Actually, the Chinese government has always been even-handed in supervising Internet service companies, regardless of whether they are foreign or domestic.

    The WTO member states, both developed and developing, have always been emphasizing that openness and supervision are two inseparable parts of market access. The American banking, insurance and telecommunications sectors are all open to foreign investment, but the US government never forgoes its governance on these sectors.

    The assertion, therefore, by some US corporations and trade associations that "China should fully and unconditionally open the market in this area" is quite one-sided. An open but governed market is more important in developing countries like China.

    In a nutshell, the Chinese government's supervision of its Internet has nothing to do with trade restrictions, but to foster a healthy environment on the Internet, protect young people and prevent some elements from using the Internet to endanger China's national security. If someone intends to challenge China's right?to govern its Internet by resorting to WTO rules, they are apparently misguided and bound to fail.

    The author is the Deputy Director and Secretary General of China Society for World Trade Organization Studies (CWTO).

     

    中文精品久久久久人妻| 亚洲?v无码国产在丝袜线观看| 久久久久亚洲av成人无码电影| 天堂新版8中文在线8| 精品无码一区二区三区爱欲九九 | 亚洲 欧美 中文 在线 视频| 亚洲精品无码MV在线观看| 狠狠精品久久久无码中文字幕| 久久精品无码专区免费| 无码人妻一区二区三区兔费| 日本无码WWW在线视频观看| 亚洲不卡中文字幕无码| 人妻无码久久精品| 日韩av无码久久精品免费| 亚洲午夜国产精品无码老牛影视 | 久久精品aⅴ无码中文字字幕重口| 无码国产乱人伦偷精品视频| 亚洲精品无码成人片久久| 特级做A爰片毛片免费看无码| 中文字幕视频在线| 久久精品中文字幕无码绿巨人| 中文字幕日韩精品无码内射| 国产成人无码精品一区在线观看| 少妇无码AV无码专区在线观看| 亚洲色中文字幕无码AV| 乱人伦中文无码视频在线观看| 超碰97国产欧美中文| 精品久久久久久无码中文字幕 | 亚洲AV无码乱码国产麻豆穿越| 国产成人无码精品久久久性色 | 狠狠躁天天躁中文字幕无码| 中文无码熟妇人妻AV在线| 制服在线无码专区| 毛片免费全部播放无码| 亚洲一区精品无码| 无码人妻精品一区二区三| 一本色道无码不卡在线观看| 一本一道av中文字幕无码| 无码精品黑人一区二区三区| 国产乱人伦Av在线无码| 人妻少妇看A偷人无码精品视频|