Home>News Center>Life
             
     

    Forbes list of big stars stirs controversy
    By Raymond Zhou (China Daily)
    Updated: 2004-02-24 08:42

    As a group, entertainment and sports stars rank among the richest in China. But their money-making capability has never been systematically gauged until Forbes came out with a bare-all list this month.

    The Forbes Celebrity 100 list, compiled and published by the Chinese edition of the US-headquartered business magazine, for the first time probed into the murky waters of those who make their fortunes by being in the spotlight. And just like its ranking of the country's top 100 richest people, this one has caused an immediate controversy.

    Actress delighted

    Zhang Ziyi, of "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" fame, was the only one on the list who was publicly delighted. The actress reportedly made 26 million yuan (US$3.1 million) last year and was No 2 on the overall power list. "It's a recognition and an encouragement," she was quoted as saying.

    Others have interpreted it more as an insult or slander. They showed either dignified or bemused indignation. Those who have talked to reporters all emphasize that their earnings have been greatly exaggerated, yet none of them was willing to go on record and correct the "errors" by providing more accurate figures.

    Han Hong, a pop singer, felt that the gap between 20 million yuan and her real income was so wide that she immediately contacted her attorney. She wanted to know whether she could take legal action against Forbes for possible negative consequences that the revelation would have on her career. "Was it legal to make up numbers and publicize it?" Han reportedly asked.

    Yu Quan, a pop duo that also raked in 20 million yuan (US$2.4 million) according to Forbes, was a little amused. It could be that high if there were no bootleggers out there, they said. "The magazine wants to have fun, and we'll let them. It doesn't matter if they say we made 1 billion a year."

    The overall ranking is made up of two parts: money earned and media exposure achieved. The calculation method is borrowed from its New York headquarters, where similar lists are compiled each year. For example, celebrity earnings are estimates based on figures culled from interviews with agents, executives and entertainment insiders.

    While most listees complained that they had never received any inquiry from the magazine, Forbes China claims that they had talked to 70 per cent of the stars, including their legal or business representatives.

    Forbes explained that the figures are pre-tax gross income when it is earned, not when it is paid. "It is a concept of sales revenue, not profit," says Hao Bing, who headed the project for the magazine.

    That may explain some of the discrepancies. For example, Sun Nan, a pop singer, earned 24 million yuan last year according to Forbes, but his agent disputed it, adding that would mean Sun appeared in one performance every three days, and inadvertently implying that his average take from each performance is over 200,000 yuan (US$24,000). Forbes, on its part, has clarified that they did find Sun had an annual total of 100 performances. Therefore, the difference may lie between his fees and his personal take.

    Promotional gimmick

    Most insiders question or rationalize the numbers from several different angles. They seem to agree that this is a promotional gimmick that the magazine is doing for itself in the China market. It knows what kind of topic can create the biggest buzz. Celebrities have always been a useful resource, says one entertainment executive, and can be used to promote its own products such as publications and conferences.

    The most serious attack comes from those who feel that Forbes has not come to grasp with the unique nature of China's entertainment industry. Some of the figures are so ludicrous, they charge, that they could only be calculated by someone totally unfamiliar with the industry. For example, Forbes may have learned a singer's stated fee and the number of appearances in a year, but the actual fee may vary widely from show to show.

    A well-known singer illustrated it to China Daily from her own experience: She regularly adjusts her fee by the nature of the performance and the size of the venue. Income from television appearances is nominal, but she could charge a six-digit fee for a single song performed in an outdoor stadium for a trade-sponsored event, such as a garment festival.

    Income from record sales is even more elusive. China's record industry is in such a bad shape that singers tend to treat it merely as a promotional tool. Whatever figures of CD sales you see in the newspaper are probably made up to make the singer and the record company look good, she said, on the condition of anonymity.

    There are whispers to the effect that the Forbes figures actually underestimated Chinese celebrities' earning power. True, you cannot calculate one set of appearance fee against all shows, but stars regularly have two sets of books, one for the tax authority and one for themselves. Actual fees are usually double the stated figures so that tax liabilities on parts of both the performer and the performing company can be sharply reduced.

    Cash transactions

    China Daily's source revealed that almost every deal is a cash transaction. They have to carry trunks of 100-yuan bills to my home before I'll sign a contract, she says.

    It used to be that neither side would pay much tax for the fee, but the performing company, usually a makeshift operation by someone who was in it for the quick money, would issue the star a hand-written note showing tax paid. But authorities started cracking down in the 1990s, and this kind of scheme could no longer work. And now many stars would pay tax based on a fee that is lower than the actual figure but still acceptable to authorities, resulting in lower official earnings.

    In November 2002, the Beijing tax department set up a database for "high-priority" individuals, mostly celebrities. Government monitoring has been raised as public attention on the issue intensified. On the Forbes list, authorities were not willing to comment.

    The celebrities do not pay tax in one place, sometimes not in one country, as is the case with basketball star Yao Ming and martial-arts film hero Jet Li, both generating significant income in the United States. And we have the obligation to keep everything confidential for tax-payers, they say.

    Secrecy good or bad?

    Investigations unveil hat some stars act as spokespersons for local tax bureaux, such as Zhao Benshan in Liaoning and Xu Fan in Beijing, says Hao Bing, the Forbes list compiler.

    But is secrecy good or bad for the industry? Celebrities claim they need it not only because it is their right to privacy, but their personal and family security depends on it. Now that the "cat" is out of the bag, they claim they'll have to fear about crimes like abductions that may be committed against them. The bodyguard business will get a boost, some quip.

    Some commentators herald the list, imperfect as it is, as a step out of the shroud of secrecy into the sunshine of transparency. As Zhou Peng, editor-in-chief for Forbes China, says, this list is intended to chronicle as well as push these industries towards maturity.

    Behind the Forbes ranking is Chinese people's intensifying gaze into the black hole of wealth creation, and accompanying it, a latent sense of envy and curiosity and an awakening to the huge potential of the most glamourous businesses.

     
      Today's Top News     Top Life News
     

    China puzzled over US filing tax complaint at WTO

     

       
     

    Chen, Annette Lu slightly wounded in shooting

     

       
     

    Specific reform objectives set for banks

     

       
     

    Bush urges allies to stick with united mission

     

       
     

    Marriage bells toll in cyber churches

     

       
     

    Chinese, French women hold dialogue

     

       
      China on show in song and story
       
      Girl, 14, becomes a mother
       
      Dazzling art works catch collectors' eyes
       
      Liver-transplant patient gives birth
       
      China final of Miss Universe to be held in "Spring City"
       
      Computer game cracked down on for discrediting China's image
       
     
      Go to Another Section  
     
     
      Story Tools  
       
      Related Stories  
       
    China star rankings hint at struggles of showbiz
       
    Yao Ming tops Forbes' China celebrity list
      Feature  
      HK pop star Edison Chen punched by youngsters  
    Advertisement
             
    无码H黄肉动漫在线观看网站| 无码超乳爆乳中文字幕久久| 熟妇人妻无码中文字幕| 天堂资源中文最新版在线一区 | 中文字幕无码播放免费| 无码av最新无码av专区| 日韩精品无码人成视频手机| 精品久久久无码人妻中文字幕| 精品久久久久久无码中文字幕| 精品国产aⅴ无码一区二区| av区无码字幕中文色| 中文字字幕在线中文无码| 青春草无码精品视频在线观| 日韩精品无码久久久久久 | 亚洲人成人无码网www电影首页 | 亚洲AV无码专区在线播放中文| 国产精品无码久久四虎| 色窝窝无码一区二区三区| 中文字幕国产| 波多野结衣中文字幕在线| 无码中文人妻在线一区二区三区| 无码色AV一二区在线播放| 国产成人精品无码一区二区| 日韩乱码人妻无码中文字幕久久| 国产丰满乱子伦无码专区| 亚洲av中文无码| 欧美一级一区二区中文字幕| 精品久久久久久久久中文字幕| 在线观看免费无码视频| 亚洲国产91精品无码专区| 中文字幕无码日韩专区免费| 亚洲人成影院在线无码观看| 亚洲av无码国产精品色在线看不卡| 国产免费黄色无码视频| 久久精品无码专区免费| 人看的www视频中文字幕| 中文字幕一区二区人妻性色| 中文字幕日本人妻久久久免费| √天堂中文www官网| 精品人妻无码专区中文字幕| 中文字幕无码久久久|