Sharing the pain

    By Raymond Zhou (China Daily)
    2011-03-18 09:18
    Large Medium Small

    Sharing the pain 

    The emotional fallout in China from Japan's disaster offers a walk down memory lane of Sino-Japanese love-hate attitudes.

    My first exposure to screen depictions of nuclear disaster was in 1984 when a Japanese television drama called Akai Giwaku was aired in China. Roughly translated as "Suspicion of Blood" in Chinese, it portrays a 17-year-old student who is accidentally contaminated by radiation. This happens in the first episode, and for the remaining 28 episodes, she fights a losing battle against blood cancer. However, it is more an affirmation of love and family than an indictment of nuclear mismanagement.

    Like me, most of my countrymen shed tears for the continuously frail protagonist with her beguiling smile and sunny disposition. Pop icon Momoe Yamaguchi, who essayed the role nine years earlier in 1975, became an instant superstar in China. This tear-jerker even provoked spasms of pessimism, with reports of a couple of teenage girls in China committing suicide because Yamaguchi's role was doomed from the beginning and no miracle happened by the end of the series.

    In a sense, this television hit, in an era when most Chinese families could receive no more than three channels if they owned a set, introduced the specter of nuclear threat just as The Day After, shown a year earlier in 1983, got Americans thinking seriously about the same issue. Unlike Hollywood disaster epics, though, it focuses on the human dimension.

    Sharing the pain

    That was also the golden age for Sino-Japanese relations when the air seemed to be filled with a palpable breeze of goodwill between the two countries. Many Chinese productions - movies and television alike - zeroed in on the suffering of both Chinese and Japanese people during the War of Resistance against Japanese Aggression (1937-45).

    For the next 20-plus years, things took a bad turn. Conflicts flared up from time to time, giving rise to increasing hostility on both sides. Even a concert of J-pop in Shanghai a few years ago, a retrospective of popular songs performed by the original Japanese singers, now with age carved into their faces and voices, met a tidal wave of vicious responses online, clearly from younger generations who were ignorant of the nation's hearty embrace of J-pop that trickled into the mainland, sometimes through local renditions.

    They got a surprise education when one of these songs, Star, was used in Feng Xiaogang's blockbuster movie If You Are the One. Feng said the song never failed to get him teary-eyed, and the youngsters now seem to share his sentiment. This film also put Hokkaido on the map for Chinese tourists. Some of the film's locations, which now carry a special meaning for us, were hard hit by the earthquake and tsunami of March 11, Chinese media reported.

    The triple whammy of earthquake, tsunami and nuclear crisis is having the sudden effect of warming a lot of Chinese hearts to Japan and its people, especially many of those who have been proudly calling themselves Japan-haters. Even though the Web still has its share of gloaters, many seem to have learned to differentiate between opposing Japanese policies and actions involving the Diaoyu Islands and the Yasukuni Shrine and showing empathy for the Japanese people in a time of devastation.

    In the early days of the disaster, as recounted in a tweet on Sina Weibo, a kindergarten boy was asked for his opinion about what happened in Japan, and he blurted out: "That's great. They're our enemies, aren't they?" That failure to tell a humanitarian tragedy apart from a national rivalry is by no means limited to the very young. It is rooted in a simplistic view of the world, which is akin to George W. Bush's "You're either with us or against us" line of thinking.

    Chinese authorities have always applied a dichotomy to the war between our two countries: "It was Japanese militants who inflicted so much pain on the Chinese people," we are told, but also, "and the Japanese people were also victims."

    The nuance seems to be lost when an emotional issue like Japan's downplaying of the Rape of Nanking in its textbooks come to the fore. Voices are drowned out when they point out different opinions in Japanese society regarding these controversies.

    The reasons are manifold: For one thing, we are constantly reminded of wartime sufferings at the hands of Japanese invaders; for another, we are conditioned to look at a country as one big box of machine programmed people with the same thinking and actions. It is inconceivable to many that even a homogeneous society like Japan's has diversity and the most vociferous ones may not be the majority.

    In a lot of ways, those indiscriminate J-haters are the mirror image of the segment in Japanese society that hates China, whose opinions are based on long-held convictions rather than evolving realities.

    It is certainly interesting to see Chinese positions diverging in the past decade. Take Japan Sinks, a disaster film made in 1973 and remade in 2006. The assumption of Armageddon as a result of tectonic plates shifting underneath the Japanese islands gave some people here vicarious gratification as they essentially applied the logic of the above-mentioned kindergarten boy. Then, another group of people came forward and said: This shows how crisis conscious Japanese are and we should learn from them in assuming such a mentality while rushing headlong into prosperity.

    The outpouring of compassion from ordinary Chinese is an indication that people are becoming increasingly aware of the common threat we face as humanity. Natural disasters such as earthquakes and tsunamis and man-made disasters such as terrorism do not make a distinction between nationalities or ethnicities. They strike randomly. When one country is hit, people everywhere feel the pain.

    How long this surge of friendliness and togetherness will last depends on the resolve and foresight of politicians in both countries - whether they will be able to place common interests above differences and whether they see good neighbors as more important than bitter rivals.

    It is impractical to expect a smooth ride into infinity, but hopefully some of the bumps will get smoothed when we take a broader view of the cosmos and the vulnerability of mankind.

    The stricken area of northeastern Japan is not familiar to most Chinese - with one exception. Sendai, the biggest city closest to the epicenter, made its first appearance in the Chinese consciousness in a high-school textbook. In it, Lu Xun, the greatest Chinese writer of the 20th century, recalled his student days attending Tohuku University in Sendai. His teacher, a certain "Mr Fujino", came through as an exemplar, though subdued, of decency, benevolence and respectability.

    When you get to know people of a foreign land on a personal level, stereotypes begin to shatter and a shared humanity emerges.

    分享按鈕
    精品亚洲A∨无码一区二区三区| 人妻中文久久久久| 最近高清中文在线字幕在线观看| 91精品国产综合久久四虎久久无码一级| 无码精品人妻一区二区三区免费看| 爆操夜夜操天天操中文| 国精无码欧精品亚洲一区| 五月丁香啪啪中文字幕| 婷婷五月六月激情综合色中文字幕| 亚洲不卡中文字幕无码| 大蕉久久伊人中文字幕| 天堂√最新版中文在线| 国产v亚洲v天堂无码网站| 国产色无码精品视频免费| 中文精品久久久久国产网址| 免费无遮挡无码视频在线观看| 人妻少妇伦在线无码专区视频| 无码人妻精品一区二区蜜桃网站| 久久综合中文字幕| 中文字幕无码乱人伦| 国产精品午夜福利在线无码| 精品无码久久久久久尤物| 亚洲日产无码中文字幕| 少妇性饥渴无码A区免费| 国内精品久久久久久中文字幕| 国产精品va在线观看无码| AV无码久久久久不卡蜜桃| 亚洲av无码乱码国产精品fc2| 一二三四在线播放免费观看中文版视频 | 亚洲AV区无码字幕中文色| 五月婷婷无码观看| 亚洲av无码成人精品区在线播放 | 97久久精品无码一区二区天美| 无码国产精品一区二区免费模式 | 国产亚洲精久久久久久无码| 无码精品国产一区二区三区免费| 性无码专区无码片| 色AV永久无码影院AV| 精品无码国产一区二区三区AV| 国产成A人亚洲精V品无码| 国产成人精品无码片区在线观看|