'Ethnic politics' poison society

    Updated: 2013-02-20 06:22

    By Thomas Chan(HK Edition)

      Print Mail Large Medium  Small 分享按鈕 0

    The idea of Hong Kong "ethnic groups" has recently gained popular traction in local media and talk shows. The concept originated in the writings of individuals advocating more autonomy and even independence of Hong Kong (an already highly autonomous territory under the "One Country, Two Systems" regime enshrined in the Basic Law). A vocal proponent of this idea has even called upon the people of Hong Kong to set up their own nation apart from the Chinese mainland.

    This has reminded us of the cultural strategy of the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) in Taiwan. In the early 1990s, as electoral politics spread across the island, theorists of the DPP had put forth the argument that there were four major ethnic groups in Taiwan: the Hoklo and Hakka peoples, mostly from Fujian province, migrants from other mainland provinces and the island's native tribes. I believe the first three groups are not necessarily independent ethnic groups, as they all belong to the race of Han people, albeit with different linguistic cultures that represent dialectical variations rather than separate languages.

    Hoklo, Hakka and other mainlanders have long co-habituated many other localities throughout China, not just in Fujian or Taiwan. Each of the supposed "ethnic groups" may entertain dissimilar social and cultural practices or customs, but the differences are not great enough to distinguish them as separate ethnic groups.

    The classification by the DDP theorists is not intended for theoretical clarity; their purpose has been political. By putting the locals (in particular the older migrants to Taiwan from southern Fujian) against those from other provinces of China (the more recent migrants), they try to demonstrate the ethnic difference between the two. Their purpose is to justify the political agenda of "Taiwan independence", to support claims that the island is a separate nation-state from China based on the independent ethnic group of the older migrants. What started as a vague and mistaken notion of ethnicity has evolved into the cultural-cum-political strategy for "Taiwan independence". This is what the French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu calls a politics of assumption, which uses and popularizes "pseudo concepts" on the basis of erroneous or dubious assumptions so that political group(s) might shape and create a new political reality.

    'Ethnic politics' poison society

    In Hong Kong, this new political reality that radicals would desire is certainly not "One Country, Two Systems", but a Hong Kong that breaks away from China. The fact that proponents of Hong Kong people as a separate ethnic group from mainland Han people were those waving the British colonial flag in recent public demonstrations would make us believe that they are in fact struggling for a new Hong Kong of the colonial past - old wine in an old bottle.

    The excessive domination of the local economy by financial capital and real estate developers has already strangled the competition and spirit of entrepreneurship in the local economy. But cross-border purchasing power of the mainland's middle class has helped to provide HK$300 billion retail sales per year (at least half of the total local sales), while creating hundreds of thousands of jobs for local Hong Kong people. As a result, unemployment has ceased to be a social problem, and the territory has been able to enjoy slow but steady economic growth. However, this dynamic has not been able to create enough uplift for the local economy's development of growth industries. The middle class is still shrinking and the younger generation has gradually lost their hope of upward mobility, especially in the aftermath of the financial tsunami which has also shrunk the local financial sector. The massive financial reserves of the Hong Kong government and near full employment locally seem to be no guarantee for social harmony and political stability. Everybody seems to be convinced that Hong Kong society is being polarized, and the recent Legislative Council election results reinforced this belief for many.

    If at this critical historical conjecture, there emerges a politically-charged pseudo concept of "ethnic groups", social polarization may nurture further political schism across the local society. In the past, political activism in Hong Kong before 1997 had been anti-colonialism and nationalistic in nature. After the handover, it has changed to the "civil society" against the government. The pseudo concept of ethnic groups is threatening to create social schism that would lead to the transformation of the current political schism. The proponents of more autonomy or independence are revolutionary in orientation and nature, even though they have publicly denied it, or, they aren't aware of their own nature. Their only means of social and political protest seems to be mass demonstration, rather than lobbying in the legislature or to the government. Growing violence on the streets (as witnessed in recent demonstrations) is not and should not be tolerated, as it would not lead to any constructive compromise politically.

    The government and society of Hong Kong should be aware of the potential destructive effect of the politics of "ethnic groups", and should not offer the concept political space to expand and grow.

    The author is head of China Business Centre, Hong Kong Polytechnic University.

    (HK Edition 02/20/2013 page1)

    亚洲中文字幕无码一去台湾| 无码国内精品久久人妻| 精品欧洲AV无码一区二区男男| 中文字幕乱码中文乱码51精品| 无码人妻精品一区二区三18禁| 最近2019年免费中文字幕高清| 久久亚洲av无码精品浪潮| 中文字幕日韩精品无码内射| 久久久久久久人妻无码中文字幕爆| 国产无遮挡无码视频免费软件| AV无码久久久久不卡蜜桃| 亚洲综合日韩中文字幕v在线| 精品无人区无码乱码大片国产| 国产网红无码精品视频| 久久亚洲中文字幕精品一区四| 免费a级毛片无码免费视频| 亚洲午夜福利AV一区二区无码| 最近免费中文字幕大全高清大全1 最近免费中文字幕mv在线电影 | 亚洲一区AV无码少妇电影☆| 亚洲一区中文字幕久久| 欧美巨大xxxx做受中文字幕| 88国产精品无码一区二区三区| 亚洲AV人无码综合在线观看| 熟妇人妻系列aⅴ无码专区友真希 熟妇人妻系列av无码一区二区 | 色综合网天天综合色中文男男| 日韩A无码AV一区二区三区| 韩国免费a级作爱片无码| 日日摸夜夜爽无码毛片精选| 最近免费中文字幕高清大全| 亚洲韩国—中文字幕| 国产在线精品一区二区中文| 中文一国产一无码一日韩| 亚洲中文字幕无码一区二区三区| 亚洲国产精品无码久久九九 | 中文字幕人妻无码一夲道 | 美丽姑娘免费观看在线观看中文版| 亚洲国产精品无码久久久久久曰| 老子影院午夜精品无码| 四虎国产精品永久在线无码| 久久中文字幕无码专区| 中文字幕乱码人妻一区二区三区 |