Do domestic helpers deserve more?

    Updated: 2013-04-13 05:47

    By Jony Lam(HK Edition)

      Print Mail Large Medium  Small 分享按鈕 0

    In a recent campaign against right of abode for domestic helpers, speakout.hk successfully went viral with a comic strip post titled "If she has the right of abode..." The strip depicts two households. On the left, captioned "today", a female Hongkonger sitting on a couch says "Maria, please sweep the floor." An expressionless Southeast Asian woman sweeping the floor says "Yes mom [sic]."

    On the right, captioned "tomorrow," the same Southeast Asian woman Maria now sits presumptuously on the same couch. "Mary, hurry up and sweep the floor!" she says. You can see her impatience through the comic symbol that looks like # on her forehead. "Yes, boss," Mary the Hongkonger says in resigned fashion as she sweeps the floor.

    This ingenious post earned speakout.hk more than 30 shares and almost 50 likes utilizing a time-tested principle in marketing: exploit common motivations and behaviors. It visualizes our worst but unfounded fear of being ruled by Southeast Asians and expresses the message in a compressed and easy to digest manner. Marketing is not a science, and accuracy may do more harm than good.

    We know for a fact that not all Hong Kong employers are amicable to their domestic helpers - in many ways. Hong Kong people's argument has always been straightforward: foreign domestic helpers know full well when they sign their employment contract that citizenship is not part of the deal.

    Recent events in Brazil could be enlightening. From April 2, a new law came into force giving domestic servants the same rights as other workers for the first time. In recent years, their rights have been gradually revised to include paid holidays, sick leave and maternity leave. After the latest adjustment, an estimated seven million housemaids and cooks are also entitled to overtime after working for a maximum of eight hours a day and 44 hours a week, among other rights.

    "Domestic work in its current form in Brazil is virtually unique in the world and is a legacy of slavery," said Brazilian Senator Lidice da Mata, a sponsor of the new constitutional amendment.

    So what is the relevance? Domestic work in Brazil and Hong Kong are both hierarchies. A legacy of Brazil's history of colonialism and slavery, Brazilians with African ancestry earn substantially less than white Brazilians due to disadvantages in education and wages. According to the World Bank, black Brazilians have levels of educational attainment only two-thirds the level of whites, which limits their access to higher paying jobs. In Hong Kong, we "import" domestic workers from Southeast Asia at below market prices.

    A lot of us believe that people are poor because they are incompetent or lazy. This is far from the truth. Domestic work in Brazil and Hong Kong exists not because wages determined by a free labor market allocate the jobs as such, but because the law makes a certain kind of people's time cheaper than others'. As reported by the BBC, when the law says domestic helpers should be treated like other workers and enjoy overtime pay in Brazil, they immediately earn between 18 to 40 percent more.

    The hypocrisy of Civic Party lawyers lies in the fact that they have no intention of challenging the status quo. In a just world, you pay people who do your laundry with an equitable amount of money, not with "rights of abode" seven years later (with costs other taxpayers who may not have employed domestic helpers have to share) in lieu of fair pay.

    Isn't it something to look forward to in the next election, when we can again decide which side to support? Do you want more hypocrites, or are you going to give the heartless a chance?

    The author is a current affairs commentator. You may contact the author at jony.lam.kh@gmail.com.

    (HK Edition 04/13/2013 page6)

    国产AⅤ无码专区亚洲AV| 久久av无码专区亚洲av桃花岛| 日韩精品无码久久久久久| 全球中文成人在线| 久久精品中文字幕无码绿巨人 | 日韩精品无码专区免费播放| 最近免费中文字幕mv在线电影| 精品无码专区亚洲| 无码国产色欲XXXX视频| 亚洲色无码播放| 伊人久久无码精品中文字幕| 亚洲精品无码99在线观看| 国产精品无码无需播放器| 亚洲AV无码乱码国产麻豆| 亚洲中文字幕无码爆乳av中文| 天堂а在线中文在线新版| 欧日韩国产无码专区| 本免费AV无码专区一区| 欧洲无码一区二区三区在线观看| 国产av无码专区亚洲av果冻传媒| 久久无码中文字幕东京热| 中文字幕手机在线观看| 最近中文字幕完整版资源| 久久久久久久人妻无码中文字幕爆| 无码不卡亚洲成?人片| 色视频综合无码一区二区三区| V一区无码内射国产| 国产网红无码精品视频| 久久Av无码精品人妻系列| 粉嫩高中生无码视频在线观看| 久久久久无码精品国产不卡| 欧洲Av无码放荡人妇网站| 色综合AV综合无码综合网站| 亚洲AV无码专区亚洲AV伊甸园| 亚洲AV无码成人精品区在线观看 | 精品久久久久久中文字幕大豆网 | 国产精品无码国模私拍视频| 国产亚洲AV无码AV男人的天堂| 日韩精品无码一区二区中文字幕| 亚洲av无码成人黄网站在线观看| 中文字幕无码精品三级在线电影|