Textbook pricing remains a hot topic

    Updated: 2013-05-09 06:52

    By Raymond So(HK Edition)

      Print Mail Large Medium  Small 分享按鈕 0

    Textbook pricing remains a hot topic

    Every year publishers of high school textbooks raise their prices, a chronic issue which has attracted much criticism. Parents have been complaining for years about the high prices. On average, an entire set of high school textbooks costs between HK$2,000 and HK$3,000. Worse still, the prices keep increasing, placing big burdens on many parents.

    This year is no exception. Publishers recently announced there will be a 3.2 percent increase in textbook prices. With inflation now above 4 percent, this increase does not seem excessive. Nevertheless, many organizations and commentators have denounced the plan. Some accuse publishers of ignoring corporate social responsibility, while others say the publishers do not work hard enough to bring prices down.

    Given the fact that everything is getting more expensive these days, the increase in textbook prices somehow is acceptable. In a free market, we cannot expect publishers to make a loss.

    This protracted debate on textbook pricing also conveys much social sentiment, which makes it difficult to analyze objectively. There are occasions when publishers try to influence the schools' decisions on their choice of textbooks. In the past, publishers used to provide free-teaching materials to schools. Some publishers may even sponsor campus renovation projects. Furthermore, some publishers make editions of textbooks obsolete by making minor revisions.

    Such "marketing" tools have created a negative image for publishers. Society has adopted the view that publishers are making excessive profits. This is more social sentiment than a fact, but, as mentioned above, the objection is strong this year even though the price increase seems reasonable.

    One reason for this phenomenon is the market structure of high school textbooks. The high school market is limited. As the population of high school students shrinks, the size of the market is getting smaller. But, to develop a set of high school textbooks is expensive. There are many development costs publishers need to recover. With a smaller market, the average cost per book will be higher. To compound the problem, there are many changes to the curriculum and syllabi of subjects in high school education. To publishers, if a textbook needs to survive in this dynamic market condition, they will try to recover development costs as quickly as possible. Textbook prices will therefore not be low.

    There is also a comprehensive and rigorous referee process in textbook production. Publishers cannot just produce a textbook at will. Publishers need to submit the textbooks to the government for formal approval, and this process can be lengthy and expensive. Of course, publishers will factor in these costs.

    One often neglected point is that writers' fees are included in textbook prices as royalty payments. If the textbook is welcomed by the market, then the writer can obtain handsome royalty payments. The downside, however, is that royalty payment can constitute substantial amounts of a textbook's price. Very often royalty payments range from 10 percent to 20 percent. Together with a direct production cost of 30 percent, heavy portions of textbook prices are merely fixed in nature and cannot be further reduced. From this perspective, if society really hopes to see a reduction in textbook prices, the current system will disappoint them.

    One way to change the system is to have official material provided by the government as textbook input. This way the costs of approval and textbook writing can be substantially reduced. Publishers can concentrate on the presentation and the pedagogical support. However, if the government is to provide official materials for textbooks, it is probable that a wave of strong debate will emerge. The government can easily produce "propaganda". Nevertheless, if nothing is done, the system will remain as is and complaints over textbook prices will occur every year.

    The author is dean of the School of Business at Hang Seng Management College.

    (HK Edition 05/09/2013 page1)

    久久精品无码一区二区三区免费| | 自慰无码一区二区三区| 国产网红主播无码精品| 国精品无码一区二区三区在线蜜臀 | 中国少妇无码专区| 亚洲AV无码精品色午夜果冻不卡| 最近中文字幕高清字幕在线视频| 国产AV无码专区亚洲AV男同 | 无码人妻精品一区二区三区99性 | 亚洲中文字幕无码久久综合网| 毛片无码免费无码播放| 人妻无码αv中文字幕久久琪琪布| 亚洲AV区无码字幕中文色| 国产在线观看无码免费视频| 无码国产精品一区二区免费3p | 无码精品A∨在线观看| 最新国产精品无码| 久久精品亚洲AV久久久无码| 中文无码字慕在线观看| 免费一区二区无码视频在线播放| av无码一区二区三区| 乱色精品无码一区二区国产盗| 久久AV高潮AV无码AV| 久久精品?ⅴ无码中文字幕| 日韩欧美群交P片內射中文| 久久无码AV中文出轨人妻| 91精品国产综合久久四虎久久无码一级| 自拍偷在线精品自拍偷无码专区| 老子午夜精品无码| 中文字幕乱码无码人妻系列蜜桃| 乱人伦人妻中文字幕无码| 开心久久婷婷综合中文字幕| 亚洲日韩VA无码中文字幕| 五月天中文字幕mv在线女婷婷五月 | 无码人妻久久一区二区三区免费丨 | 亚洲AV无码一区二三区| 中文字幕7777| 亚洲第一中文字幕| 亚洲欧美日韩在线不卡中文 | 亚洲AV永久青草无码精品|