Mockery of freedom of speech

    Updated: 2013-08-07 07:18

    By Chan Wai-keung(HK Edition)

      Print Mail Large Medium  Small 分享按鈕 0

    Mockery of freedom of speech

    Winston Churchill once said: "Everyone is in favor of free speech. Hardly a day passes without its being extolled, but some people's idea of it is that they are free to say what they like, but if anyone says anything back, that is an outrage." Through their words and actions, our anti-Beijing lawmakers, columnists and activists in Hong Kong have always proved the truth of this adage. They want free speech for themselves, but not for those who disagree with them. Worse still, these Beijing-bashers have always twisted facts to fit into their political agendas. A case in point is their recent fierce defense of the foul-mouthed school teacher Lam Wai-sze who is a member of the anti-Beijing League of Social Democrats.

    A couple of weeks ago, a video of this teacher hysterically swearing to the police intent on averting a bitter confrontation between Falun Gong practitioners and the Hong Kong Youth Care Association (HKYCA) in Mong Kok on July 14 went viral online. Meanwhile, the Junior Police Officer's Association and the Hong Kong Police Inspectors' Association issued a press release, censuring Lam for her verbal abuse.

    Last Wednesday, an Apply Daily editorial penned by anti-Beijing columnist Li Yi, however, took the lead in counteracting the censure by the police, contending that the police, being politically partial, had given preferential treatment to the HKYCA members in handling the Mong Kok confrontation. Likewise, the South China Morning Post columnist Albert Cheng lambasted the police for being indifferent to HKYCA's harassment against Falun Gong members at the scene. Echoing the accusations by Li and Cheng, lawmaker Raymond Wong Yuk-man even denounced the press release by the police associations as intimidation against Lam. On Sunday, under the spell of these anti-HKYCA notions, hundreds of defenders of Lam in a massive rally sparked by the online video shouted: "There is nothing inappropriate with Ms Lam's behavior; she just spoke out against injustice, the unfair treatment of Falun Gong by the police".

    The crux of the matter lies in the following questions: Did Lam really speak out against injustice on the afternoon of July 14? Did the HKYCA members really physically harass the Falun Gong group that afternoon? Did the police really "stand by and watch the Falun Gong group pestered" by HKYCA members as Albert Cheng suggested?

    After interviewing a dozen of the Mong Kok residents at the scene, I, as a Mong Kok district councillor, would argue that the defenders of Miss Lam have distorted the facts about the incident of July 14.

    First, the HKYCA members did not physically harass the Falun Gong practitioners on July 14 (on the contrary, according to the police, some Falun Gong members were later arrested for physical violence). Instead, they just unfurled some protest banners in front of a Falun Gong booth. On witnessing the confrontation, Lam immediately verbally abused the HKYCA members. In her view, while Falun Gong are free to say what they like, if anyone says anything back to this religious cult, that is an "outrage". Lam's view is indeed too exclusive and undemocratic. Her political ideology as well as sudden towering rages may have blinded her to the fact that, by law, any people or organizations are entitled to the right to peacefully protest against others by unfurling some banners in a public space so long as their number does not exceed 50. (In fact, the members of Falun Gong and the League of Social Democrats in the past always relished exercising this legal right to mob our national leaders, local officials and political opponents).

    Second, nor did the police turn a blind eye to HKYCA's protest against the Falun Gong at the scene as Lam and Cheng suggested. According to media report, on arriving at the scene, the police attempted to persuade the HKYCA members to leave the scene with their banners. But, the HKYCA members dissented. As I have pointed out before, by law, the police were not authorized to expel the members of HKYCA as well as of Falun Gong from the area. Nor were the Falun Gong members exclusively entitled to the area without the approval of the Lands Department. As a result, the police had no choice but to seal off the area and formed a human barricade segregating the opposing sides for fear that the confrontation would turn into a scuffle.

    There is no concrete evidence that the police favored the HKYCA members in the case. On the contrary, it is more sensible to argue that they, upholding the principle of political impartiality, did their utmost to avert the clash, shielding pedestrians from possible dangers.

    Sadly, the anti-Beijing lawmakers and columnists have taken the view that while the school teacher is free to speak foul language to protest against what the police did at the scene, if the police associations say anything back to the teacher through a press release, that is an "outrage" and even "intimidation". Is this notion held by the lawmakers and columnists too unfair and autocratic?

    To deem what the HKYCA members and the police did on the scene as unjust is too far-fetched. It was Lam as well as the anti-Beijing lawmakers and columnists who twisted the facts and made a falsehood of "injustice". To argue that "Lam spoke out against the injustice on July 14" is indeed a mockery of justice and freedom of speech.

    The author is an educator and a Yau Tsim Mong district councillor.

    (HK Edition 08/07/2013 page1)

    天堂Aⅴ无码一区二区三区| 色欲A∨无码蜜臀AV免费播| 无码AV天堂一区二区三区| 日本精品久久久中文字幕| 国产精品无码一区二区三级| 熟妇人妻系列aⅴ无码专区友真希| 午夜无码国产理论在线| 国产成人A亚洲精V品无码| 婷婷五月六月激情综合色中文字幕 | 久久无码一区二区三区少妇| 国产色无码专区在线观看| 亚洲乱码中文字幕综合| 精品人妻无码专区中文字幕 | 日韩综合无码一区二区| 在线看福利中文影院| 国产无码一区二区在线| 久久精品国产亚洲AV无码娇色| 中文午夜乱理片无码| 亚洲国产日韩欧美在线a乱码日本中文字幕高清| 国产成人无码精品一区在线观看 | 日韩av无码中文无码电影| 国产在线精品无码二区| 亚洲成a人片在线观看无码| 丝袜无码一区二区三区| 中文字幕日韩三级片| 中文字幕在线无码一区| 亚洲成A人片在线观看中文| 久久精品天天中文字幕人妻| 中文字幕人妻无码一夲道 | 久久久久久久人妻无码中文字幕爆| 国产成人无码av片在线观看不卡| 国产精品无码无片在线观看| 国产成人无码一区二区三区 | 久久无码AV一区二区三区| yellow中文字幕久久网| 日韩国产中文字幕| 乱人伦中文视频高清视频| 欧美日韩中文国产va另类电影| 免费A级毛片无码A∨中文字幕下载| 亚洲日本va中文字幕久久| 色综合天天综合中文网|