Who are the customers of a university? Students, industries, parents?

    Updated: 2013-10-16 07:17

    By Isagani R. Cruz(HK Edition)

      Print Mail Large Medium  Small 分享按鈕 0

    The appointment of Peter Mathieson as vice-chancellor of the University of Hong Kong (HKU) has raised some questions that are of interest not only to HKU but many universities around the world.

    Whether Mathieson is qualified or not is not the concern. The issue is whether students should have been included in the search committee that picked him.

    The broader issue is whether students should be represented at all in university committees.

    That issue has been settled in practice by numerous universities (including HKU) by including students at various levels of administration, sometimes all the way to governing boards.

    The issue, however, has not been settled in theory. The theoretical question is this: who is the customer of a university?

    The question might look odd from the point of view of traditional universities, particularly state-funded ones, but in this age when universities, including the state-funded variety, are asked to generate income to cover expenses, such a question needs to be faced.

    In applying for various forms of quality assessment, universities are routinely asked who they are serving. The routine answer is that a university serves its students. If that is the case and students are indeed the customers, then students should be included in all policy-making. "The customer is always right" has to be taken literally by universities.

    This particular answer, however, leads to thorny questions. How can students tell which learning areas will be useful to them in their lives after graduation? How can students be experts in pedagogy, teaching styles, scientific research methods, and so on, unless they take on faith what and how their teachers teach them? Is curriculum design, like product design, supposed to be based on what students want, rather than need?

    There have been several attempts to make students part of curriculum design. In teaching strategies such as "the contract method," for example, some teachers ask their students what they want to take up during a term and then let the students decide on the requirements for a particular subject.

    A serious challenge to this routine answer, however, appeared with the Bologna Process in Europe. Despite protests by students and teachers, university administrators agreed that the customer of a university is business and industry. Decrying a perceived "mismatch" between what universities teach and what industry needs, industry has become more active in curriculum design. In projects such as "dual education", students are even asked to spend a huge portion of their school time working in corporations rather than sitting in classrooms. From the point of view of industry, students should not have any voice in their formation. Students are seen as products, much like products of a factory.

    In places where parents shoulder the tuition fees of students, universities sometimes say that parents are their customers. There are schools where parents are included in policy-making. Some universities cannot raise tuition without parents agreeing and, in the process, demanding certain changes in curriculum or administration.

    The theoretical issue has not been solved to anyone's satisfaction. This leads to drawn-out debates about the role of university leaders. There is a trend to choose managers over scholars as presidents or chancellors. HKU, for example, has defended its choice by pointing to the proven talent of Mathieson to "secure finances". Some other universities, also world-ranked like HKU, prefer a financial genius to an intellectual giant.

    In fact, an intellectual giant, such as a Nobel laureate, may not necessarily know how to lead a university. Not all geniuses, for example, can speak before a large audience and stir them into action - something that university leaders have to do in times of crisis, economic or political.

    One remembers the philosopher Plato's derision of the Greek poetic genius Homer as a general. Homer, in The Iliad, wrote about how various generals commanded their armies during the Trojan War. If Homer really knew how to wage war, said Plato, he would have made a great general, but nobody made him a general in real life. Clearly, argued Plato, people know better than to trust a genius.

    The author is president of the Manila Times College and former Philippine under-secretary (deputy minister) of education.

    (HK Edition 10/16/2013 page1)

    无码丰满熟妇juliaann与黑人| 无码国产精品一区二区免费模式| 日韩人妻无码精品久久久不卡| 欧美精品中文字幕亚洲专区| V一区无码内射国产| 亚洲国产精品无码av| 久久中文精品无码中文字幕| 中文字幕无码成人免费视频| 免费A级毛片无码A∨中文字幕下载| 中文字幕日韩精品在线| 中文无码熟妇人妻AV在线| 极品粉嫩嫩模大尺度无码视频| 一本加勒比hezyo无码专区| 日本中文字幕在线视频一区| 亚洲精品无码午夜福利中文字幕 | 中文字幕本一道先锋影音| 国产成人无码A区在线观看视频| 亚洲精品午夜无码专区| 无码不卡av东京热毛片| 久久精品一区二区三区中文字幕| 亚洲乱码中文字幕综合| 亚洲va中文字幕无码久久| 亚洲免费无码在线| 亚洲伊人成无码综合网| 在线中文字幕播放| 日韩成人无码中文字幕| 日本阿v网站在线观看中文 | 中文字幕无码一区二区三区本日| 精品无码人妻一区二区三区品| 亚洲AV日韩AV永久无码久久| 一本色道无码道在线观看| 亚洲va无码手机在线电影| 亚洲熟妇无码另类久久久| 夜夜添无码一区二区三区| 亚洲国产精品无码AAA片| 亚洲V无码一区二区三区四区观看| 性无码专区无码片| 国产成A人亚洲精V品无码性色| 国产精品无码久久四虎| 亚洲精品无码永久在线观看 | 中文字幕在线免费|