Filibustering tactics destructive in HK

    Updated: 2014-04-17 05:41

    By Raymond So(HK Edition)

      Print Mail Large Medium  Small 分享按鈕 0

    Financial Secretary John Tsang presented his budget speech in February. Since then, there have been many saying the budget did not meet people's expectations. Some political groups in the Legislative Council have made it clear they will use filibusters to delay passing of the budget. The filibustering strategy has created uncertainty. If the budget is not passed, this will affect the operations of the public sector. Perhaps this is what the opposition camp really wants.

    Of course, the budget could not meet everybody's expectations. By definition, a budget is a resource allocation exercise. Given that resources are scarce, the budget cannot allocate resources to everyone. In the past, the budget did not make everyone happy - yet every budget was still passed in LegCo. The reason was simple - as long as there were "sweeteners" in the budget - it was passed. Also, previously Hong Kong people did not expect the government to have much of a role in the economy. They did not have great expectations about the budget.

    Filibustering tactics destructive in HK

    But all this changed with the 2011 budget. At the time, the financial secretary faced strong opposition when he pledged to inject HK$6,000 into every resident's Mandatory Provident Fund (MPF) accounts. Lawmakers threatened not to pass the budget. Under tremendous pressure, the financial secretary agreed not to go through with the plan. Instead, Hong Kong residents were given HK$6,000 in cash. This showed the lawmakers that their threats could work.

    Last year, some opposition groups adopted a filibustering strategy and nearly succeeded in blocking the budget. This year they are using the strategy again.

    On the surface, the case for use of filibustering is not strong. It is true it is often employed by opposition groups to confront the establishment. Filibustering is commonly used around the world, but usually without destructive intentions. Very often opposition parties employ it because they want to negotiate a better deal. Filibustering is used as a tool for negotiation rather than as a way to paralyze governments.

    However, filibustering in Hong Kong is used with destructive intentions. According to the opposition groups, the rationale for filibustering is because the government did not introduce a universal pension system. But this argument is completely unreasonable. Again, the government cannot do everything people want. No single budget can meet the demands of all parties. Saying that a filibuster will be used because there is no universal pension system is an excuse - not a legitimate reason. The real reason for filibustering in Hong Kong is to paralyze the government and give it a hard time. For the opposition, this strategy is a sure winner.

    Filibustering tactics destructive in HK

    Under the existing electoral system, opposition groups are guaranteed a seat in LegCo if they can get the support of the most radical voters. If LegCo candidates appear radical then they have a big chance of being elected. In order to get much-needed votes, the radical members appear to be anti-government. Not only can they consolidate their original supporters, they can also absorb new blood into their camp. Filibustering can fulfill all these objectives. So it is a very effective strategy for radical groups.

    Also, filibustering can be employed to annoy the pro-establishment camp. When a filibuster is introduced to LegCo, lawmakers need to stay there for long periods of time. For pro-government forces, this is a complete waste of time. Some are frustrated or may even be absent from LegCo. This gives the media opportunities to write stories criticizing the government. Therefore, filibustering can also hurt the reputation of the pro-government forces.

    Filibustering is a sign that the opposition camp will try anything to stop the normal functions of government. In future, there are many other bills likely to face a filibuster. More disagreements will emerge. The outlook is not optimistic at all.

    The author is dean of School of Business at Hang Seng Management College.

    (HK Edition 04/17/2014 page9)

    日韩va中文字幕无码电影| 亚洲av无码乱码国产精品| 中文字幕无码精品亚洲资源网久久| 国产精品无码专区| 日本无码小泬粉嫩精品图| 中文字幕日韩精品无码内射| 亚洲国产精品无码久久98| 亚洲综合日韩中文字幕v在线| 国产精品无码专区在线观看| 亚洲欧洲日产国码无码网站| 久草中文在线观看| 亚洲一区二区三区无码中文字幕 | 毛片无码全部免费| 亚洲VA成无码人在线观看天堂| 亚洲国产人成中文幕一级二级 | 精品久久无码中文字幕| 蜜桃视频无码区在线观看| 国产午夜片无码区在线播放| 亚洲国产精品无码专区| 欧洲精品无码一区二区三区在线播放 | 亚洲精品无码久久不卡| 国产成人无码a区在线视频| 国产办公室秘书无码精品99| 少妇伦子伦精品无码STYLES| 亚洲熟妇无码乱子AV电影| 免费a级毛片无码a∨免费软件 | 亚洲看片无码在线视频| 日本免费在线中文字幕| 国产中文字幕在线视频| 日本免费中文字幕| 最近最新中文字幕完整版| 最近中文字幕高清中文字幕无| 久久精品中文騷妇女内射| 亚洲欧美日韩一区高清中文字幕| 日本中文字幕一区二区有码在线| 91视频中文字幕| 最近中文字幕高清免费中文字幕mv| 天堂网www中文在线资源| 无码人妻丰满熟妇啪啪网站| 国产品无码一区二区三区在线蜜桃| 13小箩利洗澡无码视频网站免费|