久久久无码人妻精品无码_6080YYY午夜理论片中无码_性无码专区_无码人妻品一区二区三区精99

   
 
Sotheby's fights for its brand in mainland China
By Jessie Chen(China IP)
Updated: 2012-10-30

Auction is a special type of commodity transaction in the human society. It first appeared in ancient Rome, and became an industry in Europe in the 17th and 18th century. After hundreds of years of development with the market economy, the ancient but burgeoning industry is spreading its unique charm around the globe. And it’s inevitable that it is encountering some IP problems.

Sotheby's fights for its brand in mainland China

With the growth of the world economy, the auction industry has also entered its age of prosperity. As one of the most famous auction houses, Sotheby’s was founded in 1744 in London. It is the only auction company in the world that is listed in the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE). Sotheby’s has more than 90 offices located in over 40 countries and regions around the globe with over 250 auctions held every year. In 1974, Sotheby’s set up an office in Hong Kong, which marked its entrance into the Asian market. Later on in 1994 and 2007, it set up two more offices in Shanghai and Beijing respectively, and held an auction preview in mainland China in 1994. Recently, in Sotheby’s Hong Kong Spring 2012 Auctions, the total volume of transaction exceeded 2.4 billion HKD.

In recent years, auction has been increasingly heated up in China. No matter artworks or luxuries, there are more and more people willing to participate in these auctions. “Following Famous Brands” became a natural phenomenon in this industry.

Sotheby's fights for its brand in mainland China
The Global Gross Turnover of Sotheby's
In 2003, Sichuan Su Fu Bi Auction Company (Sichuan SFB), whose Chinese name “蘇富比” is the same with the Chinese translation of Sotheby’s, was established in Chengdu, Sichuan Province.

It has successfully organized some large auctions including the auction of stuffs that had travelled with “Shenzhou V” and “Shenzhou VI” spacecrafts. The global itinerant exhibition of the giant painting Ode to China had great influence both at home and abroad.

However, its organizers “Sichuan SFB” and “China Softbill Auction” seemed quite mysterious in the eyes of the public, and people couldn’t help wondering what on earth is their relationship with the British Sotheby’s.

Prelude to the “蘇富比” trademark dispute

Though no one will doubt about the publicity of Sotheby’s in the international market, in the domestic market of China, the dispute concerning the right of the use of the “蘇富比” trademark has a long story.

Sotheby’s said that “蘇富比” is its official Chinese trade name. It has registered the “Sotheby’s” trademark in class 35 in many countries and regions in the world, and the 蘇富比” trademark in Hong Kong and Taiwan.

On May 15th, 2006, it applied for the registration of the “蘇富比” trademark in class 35 category—Auction and Related Services—to the Trademark Office of the State Administration for Industry and Commerce of the People’s Republic of China (SAIC). However, Sichuan SFB applied for the registration of the “蘇 富比” trademark on January 14th, 2004, and has been using that trademark in its commercial activities.

In August, 2008, Beijing No.2 Intermediate People’s Court, Beijing Higher People’s Court and the Supreme Court together made the final judgment: Sichuan SFB has infringed upon the exclusive right of using the registered trademark as well as the unregistered wellknown trademark of Sotheby’s Auction House, and has constituted unfair competition. Sichuan SFB should stop using the registered “Sotheby’s” trademark and the “蘇富比” trademark or similar marks in auctions or the related publicity campaigns from the date when the judgment comes into effect, and compensate Sotheby’s for reasonable fees.

Dispute caused by the ruling of the trademark appeal board

Sichuan SFB is an auction enterprise in mainland China. The company was registered in the competent authorities in 2003 and applied for the registration of the “蘇富比” trademark on January 14th, 2004.

Sotheby’s appealed to SAIC, saying that Sotheby’s changed the Chinese translation of its name “蘇富比” to “蘇富比” at Hong Kong commercial registry on March 14th, 2008, sued Sichuan SFB in court because it believed that it is an internationally famous enterprise, and required that Sichuan SFB stop using any mark related to “蘇富比.” On December 31st, 2011, the Trademark Appeal Board of SAIC made the ruling for the re-examination of the “蘇富比” trademark dispute: the registered trade name “Sotheby’s” of the Sotheby’s Auction house in the UK does not constitute similarity with the disputed trademark “蘇富比.” Sotheby’s application for registration of “蘇富比” was later than the applicant of the disputed trademark. Therefore, Sotheby does not have “the existing earlier right” of the trademark, and cannot be considered as having been using the trademark “蘇富比” and gained certain influence in the auction industry before the application of the disputed trademark. The registration of the disputed trademark did not violate the stipulations in Article 13 and Article 31 of the Trademark Law that “An application for registration of a trademark shall not be of such a nature as to infringe the existing earlier right of another person”. According to Article 33 and Article 34 of the Trademark Law, the disputed trademark “蘇富比” was approved for registration.

The ruling of the Trademark Appeal Board of SAIC and the decision of the court on the “蘇富比” trademark dispute were contradictory. The news was hotly debated in the circles of law, auction, trademark, collection and financial news.

Points of legal disputes

(1). Whether “Sotheby’s” and “蘇富比” constitute the only corresponding relation

Pro: They constitute the only corresponding relation.

In 1998, Sotheby’s registered the “蘇富比” trademark for many kinds of products including pictures, artworks, tapestry and so on. Later on, it went on to register the same trademark for many other products and services. In China, Sotheby’s has the exclusive right to use this trademark on these registered commodities and services. In 2006, Sotheby’s applied for the registration of the “蘇富比” trademark in the category of Auctions and Related Services to the Trademark Office of China. The court has confirmed the fact that the “蘇富比” trademark is an unregistered well-known trademark in class 35 of Auctions and Related Services, which has legal force.

Con: They do not constitute the only corresponding relation.

The trademark in dispute (“蘇富比”) is very much different from the reference mark (Sotheby’s) in word formation and pronunciation. In addition, in Oxford Guide to British and American Culture and Oxford Illustrated English-Chinese Dictionary, Sotheby’s is translated as “索斯(思)比拍賣行,” instead of “蘇富比.” Therefore, the evidence provided by Sotheby’s cannot prove that before the application date of the trademark in dispute (“蘇富比”), there had established the sole corresponding relation between “Sotheby’s” and “蘇富比.”

(2). Whether unregistered well-known trademark is applicable in mainland China Pro: Applicable

According to Article 6 of Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property, no matter a wellknown trademark is registered or not, as long as the authorities of the country, where the trademark is registered or used, recognize that the trademark is already well-known, the trademark can be protected.

The interested party has the right to apply for cancellation of a registered mark that is the same or similar to their trademark and prohibiting the use of the trademark. Article 13.1 of the Trademark Law of China stipulates that “A trademark shall not be registered and its use shall be prohibited where the trademark constitutes a reproduction, an imitation, or a translation, of a well-known trademark of another person not registered in China and is likely to lead to confusion, if the trademark is the subject of an application for registration in respect of goods which are identical or similar to the goods to which the wellknown trademark applies.”

Con: Not applicable

An important premise for judging whether an unregistered mark is well-known or not is the continuous business operation in Mainland China as a legal entity. Sotheby’s cannot be regarded as a legal entity in the auction industry in Mainland China according to the regulations in the Auction Law and the Law on Protection of Cultural Relics. Therefore, for foreign auction enterprises, the auction trademarks are not applicable to “unregistered well-known trademark,” and their auction previews in Mainland China are all unlawful acts.

Continuation of the “蘇富比” trademark dispute

It is reported that after 8 years of dispute, the “蘇富比” trademark case still has no final result, and the lawsuit was heard from the Hong Kong court to the Beijing court. China IP interviewed Tian Xiaodong, partner of AN, TIAN, ZHANG & PARTNERS on the different opinions of the related parties in the “蘇富比” dispute. As the attorney for Sotheby’s, Mr. Tian told China IP that Beijing No.2 Intermediate People’s Court, Beijing Higher People’s Court and the Supreme Court had all confirmed the fact that the “蘇富比” trademark is an unregistered well-known trademark in class 35 of Auctions and Related Services, and the court verdict had already came into force and had legal effect. As to the ruling of the Trademark Appeal Board in the review of adjudication on opposition, Sotheby’s believes that the ruling has an obvious mistake, and the company has appealed to Beijing No.1 Intermediate People’s Court concerning the ruling of the Trademark Appeal Board. Besides, it is also actively assisting the local court to take compulsory execution measures according to the effective court verdict concerning the trademark infringement and unfair competition. Mr. Tian emphasized that the ruling of the Trademark Appeal Board was still in the process of judicial procedure, which does not have legal force yet.

For Sotheby’s that has hundreds of years of history, probably it will have to face again the serious impact of the trademark dispute.

(Translated by Snow Li)



The J-Innovation

Steve Jobs died the month that the latest Nobel Prize winners were announced. The coincidence lends itself to speculation about inevitability.

Volunteer team bails out busy court

Government supports unique intellectual property fund

IP service providers showcase products

Experts call for standardization of IP services

久久久无码人妻精品无码_6080YYY午夜理论片中无码_性无码专区_无码人妻品一区二区三区精99

    久热免费在线观看| a天堂资源在线观看| 久久人人爽人人爽人人av| 天美星空大象mv在线观看视频| 国产一二三四五| 激情五月婷婷久久| 国产真实老熟女无套内射| 午夜在线观看av| 欧美s码亚洲码精品m码| 日本黄xxxxxxxxx100| 国内自拍视频网| 人妻少妇精品无码专区二区| 欧美专区第二页| 免费观看精品视频| 99精品一级欧美片免费播放| 蜜桃免费在线视频| 黄色一级片播放| 青青在线视频免费观看| 99中文字幕在线| 日本888xxxx| 日本一本二本在线观看| 999一区二区三区| 四虎免费在线观看视频| 蜜臀一区二区三区精品免费视频| 狠狠爱免费视频| 黄色成人在线看| 男人c女人视频| 三年中文高清在线观看第6集| 国产三级三级看三级| 欧美xxxxx在线视频| 777久久久精品一区二区三区| 蜜臀av色欲a片无码精品一区 | 成人免费视频久久| 国产深夜男女无套内射| 国产一区二区在线免费播放| 黄色特一级视频| 偷拍盗摄高潮叫床对白清晰| 亚洲精品20p| 亚洲77777| 天天干天天干天天干天天干天天干| 男人日女人bb视频| www一区二区www免费| 大荫蒂性生交片| www婷婷av久久久影片| 日韩中文字幕在线不卡| 欧美美女黄色网| 中文字幕色呦呦| 中文字幕第66页| 亚洲制服在线观看| 经典三级在线视频| 日本美女爱爱视频| 99re6这里有精品热视频| 九一免费在线观看| 欧美久久久久久久久久久久久久| 亚洲 自拍 另类小说综合图区| 精品99在线视频| 日韩少妇内射免费播放18禁裸乳| 国产曰肥老太婆无遮挡| av免费观看大全| 国产欧美日韩网站| 18禁男女爽爽爽午夜网站免费| 青青在线视频观看| 人妻内射一区二区在线视频| 日韩在线视频在线观看| 成人一区二区三| 亚洲欧美日韩综合网| 自拍一级黄色片| 草草草视频在线观看| 天堂…中文在线最新版在线| 看av免费毛片手机播放| 91看片就是不一样| 五月天亚洲视频| 亚洲综合在线一区二区| wwwwww欧美| 青娱乐自拍偷拍| 青青在线视频免费| 毛片毛片毛片毛| wwwjizzjizzcom| 精品国产免费av| 亚洲黄色av网址| 欧美日韩视频免费在线观看| 800av在线免费观看| 日本黄网站免费| 男人添女人下面免费视频| 91免费视频黄| 国产精品免费入口| 粉色视频免费看| 中文字幕人妻熟女人妻洋洋| 男女av免费观看| 污污视频在线免费| 怡红院av亚洲一区二区三区h| 九九热精品在线播放| 97精品国产97久久久久久粉红| 女人天堂av手机在线| 97人人爽人人| 女人喷潮完整视频| 在线免费黄色小视频| 午夜精品久久久久久久无码| 四季av一区二区三区| wwwwww欧美| 91看片在线免费观看| 97视频在线免费| 亚洲国产日韩欧美在线观看| 美脚丝袜脚交一区二区| 亚洲娇小娇小娇小| 国产黄视频在线| 亚洲国产欧美91| aa免费在线观看| 日韩精品免费一区| 99re精彩视频| 男人的天堂99| a级片一区二区| 亚洲 激情 在线| 免费高清在线观看免费| 一级黄色片播放| 最新国产黄色网址| 免费无遮挡无码永久视频| 午夜啪啪福利视频| 国产aaaaa毛片| 免费成人午夜视频| 国产精品无码电影在线观看| 五月天视频在线观看| 老头吃奶性行交视频| 婷婷激情四射五月天| 国产av熟女一区二区三区| 涩涩网站在线看| 91国产精品视频在线观看| 黄色www网站| 免费看日本黄色| japanese在线视频| 天堂在线一区二区三区| 天天天干夜夜夜操| 国产男女无遮挡| 免费观看美女裸体网站| 欧美人与动牲交xxxxbbbb| 在线免费看v片| 午夜在线观看av| 四虎永久在线精品无码视频| 日韩av新片网| 久久国产午夜精品理论片最新版本| 中文字幕第22页| 亚洲一级片网站| 手机看片福利日韩| 日日摸天天爽天天爽视频| 男人日女人bb视频| 国产精品一区二区免费在线观看| 97超碰在线人人| 欧日韩免费视频| 波多野结衣综合网| 人妻无码久久一区二区三区免费| 99久久免费观看| 免费看毛片的网址| 欧洲精品一区二区三区久久| 无码av天堂一区二区三区| 日本一本中文字幕| www.日本少妇| 黄色一级在线视频| 国产综合中文字幕| 国产视频九色蝌蚪| 日韩免费毛片视频| 日韩一级免费在线观看| 午夜免费精品视频| 视色视频在线观看| 久久国产这里只有精品| 孩娇小videos精品| 国产福利精品一区二区三区| 91热视频在线观看| 黄黄视频在线观看| 97视频在线免费| 日韩精品一区二区三区久久| av片中文字幕| 91最新在线观看| 91精产国品一二三产区别沈先生| 中文字幕一区二区三区四区五区人| 潘金莲一级淫片aaaaaa播放1| 日韩一级片一区二区| 国产3p露脸普通话对白| 91传媒久久久| 亚洲一区二区三区四区五区xx| www.com污| 激情成人开心网| 97在线免费公开视频| 日韩欧美国产片| 天堂а√在线中文在线| 5月婷婷6月丁香| 国产一级特黄a大片免费| 亚洲精品国产久| 欧洲精品在线播放| 免费在线观看的av网站| 色91精品久久久久久久久| 国产成人三级视频| 激情伊人五月天| 精品久久久久久无码国产| 91插插插影院| 欧美黑人经典片免费观看| 国产xxxxx视频| 中文字幕一区二区三区四区五区人 | 亚洲老女人av| 男女激烈动态图| 国产亚洲欧美在线视频|