Top court official: Judges should take new view of green cases

    By CAO YIN (China Daily) Updated : 2015-11-30

    Judges must change the way they handle environmental disputes, modernize their skill sets and stop favoring businesses over damaged ecology, according to an official at China's top court.

    With environmental disputes increasing rapidly, the need for judges to adapt to revised laws, new case precedents and to understand their role in environmental protection has become more acute, the official said.

    Wang Xuguang, deputy chief judge of the Environment and Ecology Tribunal under the Supreme People's Court, said that since last year there have been more than 230,000 environmental cases.

    In 2014, all intermediate people's courts in China were told to set up tribunals specializing in environmental disputes.

    Chinese courts have also accepted 36 environmental cases in the public interest since Jan 1, when the revised Environmental Protection Law took effect, but only two verdicts have been issued, the top court said.

    "Damage evaluation is a big challenge in tackling environmental disputes, as it is a technical process that involves complicated calculations," Wang said.

    Assessing the damage and how much money is needed to remedy a situation requires a great deal of time for judges to reach a verdict, according to Wang.

    Wang also said the time consuming evaluation process is one reason that only a small number of verdicts have been reached in environmental public interest litigation.

    Judges have been told to discuss assessments with authorities, such as forestry and mineral departments, in regions where the damage occurred.

    However, difficult damage assessments are not a fundamental obstacle to dealing with environmental disputes, Wang said, adding: "After all, what we do is to judge. When the damage is difficult to account for and the evaluation cost is too great, we must still give a verdict."

    A further challenge seen in lower-level courts is the interpretation of laws allowing nongovernmental organizations to file lawsuits against polluters on behalf of the public. Some courts have rejected these cases, while others have accepted them.

    In August, for example, an environmental group accused eight chemical plants of polluting the Tengger Desert, but the city court in Zhongwei, Ningxia Hui autonomous region, refused to consider the case. It ruled that the organization did not meet the legal requirements for such an action.

    The new law states that an NGO must have been registered for at least five years to sue on behalf of the public.

    But in Nanping, Fujian province, a case filed by the Beijing-based group Friends of Nature was accepted by the local court, although the group did not met the registration requirement. The group won the case on Nov 2, with the court ordering the plants to pay 1.27 million yuan ($198,730) toward forest restoration work

    "We should allow more NGOs to bring public interest litigation. Protecting the environment is the key, so we must handle such disputes," Wang said.

    Gan Daixing, a judge in the Nanping case, said Friends of Nature had not been registered for at least five years, but it had engaged in environmental work for a long time before registering.

    "The forest had been damaged and there was an urgent need to restore it. In this case, we gave approval to the NGO because it had been engaged in such work for more than five years," Gan said. "After all, environmental restoration is the priority."

    成人无码网WWW在线观看| 惠民福利中文字幕人妻无码乱精品 | 超清无码无卡中文字幕| 熟妇人妻中文字幕无码老熟妇| 中文字幕手机在线视频| 人妻无码久久精品| 无码aⅴ精品一区二区三区浪潮| 最新中文字幕在线观看| 中文午夜乱理片无码| 蜜桃视频无码区在线观看| 无码AV中文一区二区三区| 无码精品A∨在线观看免费| 欧美日韩中文字幕久久伊人| 伊人久久一区二区三区无码| 亚洲av无码国产精品色在线看不卡 | 色综合久久无码五十路人妻| 免费A级毛片无码无遮挡内射 | 91中文字幕在线观看| 免费无码午夜福利片| 久久久久久无码Av成人影院| 亚洲国产精品无码久久久秋霞2 | 在线播放无码后入内射少妇| 中文字幕一区二区三区在线观看| 中文字幕人妻丝袜乱一区三区 | 中文有码vs无码人妻| 亚洲成A∨人片天堂网无码| 久久精品无码一区二区三区免费 | 日韩AV无码精品人妻系列| 亚洲精品无码高潮喷水在线| 国产亚洲大尺度无码无码专线 | 亚洲国产精品无码久久SM| 18禁超污无遮挡无码免费网站| 直接看的成人无码视频网站| 综合久久久久久中文字幕亚洲国产国产综合一区首 | 性无码免费一区二区三区在线| 亚洲日韩精品无码一区二区三区 | 国产色爽免费无码视频| AV无码久久久久不卡蜜桃| 亚洲日韩欧洲无码av夜夜摸| 无码午夜人妻一区二区三区不卡视频 | 精品人妻少妇嫩草AV无码专区|