久久久无码人妻精品无码_6080YYY午夜理论片中无码_性无码专区_无码人妻品一区二区三区精99

The relics of 9/11

Updated: 2012-06-17 07:45

By Patricia Cohen(

The New York Times

)

  Print Mail Large Medium  Small

The relics of 9/11

Unhealed wounds complicate the choices for a new museum

It seemed self-evident at the time: a museum devoted to documenting the events of September 11, 2001, would have to include photographs of the hijackers who turned four passenger jets into missiles. Then two and a half years ago, plans to use the pictures were made public.

New York City's fire chief protested that such a display would "honor" the terrorists. Groups representing rescuers, survivors and victims' families asked how anyone could even think of showing the faces of the men who killed their relatives, colleagues and friends.

The anger took some museum officials by surprise.

"You don't create a museum about the Holocaust and not say that it was the Nazis who did it," said Joseph Daniels, chief executive of the memorial and museum foundation.

In the end, the museum decided to display the photographs, but in shrunken form, the faces a little bigger than a thumbnail. And they will have evidence stickers from the F.B.I. attached.

Such are the exquisite sensitivities that surround every detail in the creation of the National September 11 Memorial Museum, which after eight years of planning is being built on land that many revere as hallowed ground.

Alice Greenwald, the director of the new museum, and her team must simultaneously honor the dead and the survivors; preserve an archaeological site and its artifacts; and try to offer a comprehensible explanation of a once inconceivable occurrence.

The relics of 9/11

"Whose truth is going to be in that museum?" asked Sally Regenhard, whose son, Christian, a firefighter, died in the north tower.

Even the name - "Memorial Museum" - is something of a contradiction in terms. In the context of a memorial, for example, the five-meter, 1.3-metric-ton crossbeam where Mass was said every day during the cleanup is a sacred relic. In a museum, it is simply evidence.

"Museums are about understanding, about making meaning of the past," said James Gardner, who oversees the nation's legislative archives, presidential libraries and museums. "A memorial fulfills a different need; it's about remembering and evoking feelings in the viewer, and that function is antithetical to what museums do."

Sifting Through Pain

As the former associate director of the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, Ms. Greenwald knows a lot about ghastly things. Yet even that museum did not have to wrestle with the challenge of being built where the horrors had occurred and while the families of victims were still grieving.

Many families are upset, for instance, about a plan to place about 14,000 unidentified or unclaimed remains in the museum below ground. The repository will be sealed off from everyone but family members. Visitors will just see a wall inscribed with a quotation from Virgil: "No day shall erase you from the memory of time."

Seventeen family members have filed suit against the city as part of an effort to reopen the decision. They view it as degrading to set the remains in a museum below ground. Rosaleen Tallon, whose brother, Sean, a firefighter, died in the north tower, said the insensitivity was mirrored in the museum's decision to stock its gift shop with $40 souvenir key chains engraved with the Virgil phrase.

"They're marketing the headstones of our loved ones on key chains,"she said. "How disgusting is that?"

But to Ms. Greenwald, the decision to keep the remains underground represented an effort to fulfill a longstanding promise to other families who had sought, above all, to ensure that the remains stayed at bedrock.

"It's been a very difficult, fascinating and challenging process"to juggle competing visions of what the museum should be, she said.

A subtle map of divisions surfaced that ran along class, geographic and political lines: New Yorkers found outsiders meddlesome; families of uniformed rescue workers were resentful of Wall Streeters' moneyed influence; critics disdained those willing to compromise.

But with a few notable exceptions, Ms. Greenwald has been widely praised for her curatorial judgment as well as for her diplomatic skills.

"She has handled this thing with sensitivity,"said Charles Wolf, whose wife, Katherine, was killed in the attack. "She is the one who gave us all confidence in the whole process."

Difficult Decisions

The museum has more than 4,000 artifacts, from a wedding band to a 13-metric-ton composite of several tower floors that collapsed into a stack, like pancakes, and then fused together. There are photographs of men and women jumping out of windows, burned and mutilated bodies,

scattered and blood-soaked limbs.

There are thousands of harrowing firstperson recollections, and photographs and videos from survivors and witnesses. Many victims' final phone calls were preserved. Flight 93's cockpit recorder captured the hijackers' last words and a flight attendant's begging for her life.

Which of it should be on display?

"We have to transmit the truth without being absolutely crushed by it,"Mr. Daniels, the chief executive, said. "We don't want to retraumatize people."

Curators reviewed hundreds of recordings. The family of Betty Ong, the flight attendant on American Airlines Flight 11, which hit the north tower, for example, gave the museum a tape of her calmly informing ground control of the terror transpiring around her.

"It's the most remarkable demonstration of professionalism under duress that I think anyone will ever hear, and they wanted us to include it because they felt it said so much about who she was,"Ms. Greenwald said.

The family of Mary Fetchet, a member of the foundation's advisory board, donated the recording of her 24-year-old son Brad's last phone call from the south tower, telling her not to worry.

A third recording was of a 911 operator tenderly trying to comfort a woman during her terrifying final moments.

As she listened, Ms. Greenwald kept thinking of a comment made by the museum consultant Barbara Kirshenblatt-Gimblett. "I'll never forget it because it just ripped me apart when she said it, that we need to look at this kind of material as another form of human remains,"Ms. Greenwald said. "We need to use it judiciously."

In the end, they decided to make Brad Fetchet's and Betty Ong's voices available, and to archive the other. "This was not meant to be a public moment,"Ms. Greenwald said of the 911 call.

Reversible Choices

The relics of 9/11

Over time the team also pulled back further from exhibiting graphic carnage. Ms. Greenwald explained that there were other ways to convey horror, as when it is reflected in the faces of witnesses. "The historical reality is that there were body parts littering Lower Manhattan,"she said. "We do not feel the need to display that."

Opinions about whether to include images of trapped victims leaping from the flaming towers were mixed. Ms. Greenwald and Mr. Daniels decided to use photographs, but not video, and only if the person jumping could not be identified.

And absent from the space so far are any "composites,"the chunks of compressed floors. Some families are concerned that despite assurances and tests, composites could contain body matter.

"Museum officials thought this was a very interesting exhibit,"said Diane Horning, who lost her 26-year-old son, Matthew. "To us, it was human remains."

Still, the material that will be on display can be devastating, and the architectural design includes "early exits"along the museum route, enabling distressed visitors to duck out.

Many of the decisions Ms. Greenwald and her colleagues are making today may be unmade in the future. Future curators will choose differently as time passes, anguish eases, and America's position in the world shifts.

As Ms. Greenwald said, "This is a museum without an ending."

The New York Times

(China Daily 06/17/2012 page9)

久久久无码人妻精品无码_6080YYY午夜理论片中无码_性无码专区_无码人妻品一区二区三区精99

    精品卡一卡二卡三卡四在线| 国产女人水真多18毛片18精品视频| 午夜私人影院久久久久| 777奇米成人网| 久久99精品国产麻豆婷婷洗澡| 国产日产欧美精品一区二区三区| 成人精品gif动图一区| 一区二区三区欧美亚洲| 91精品久久久久久久久99蜜臂| 精品一区二区三区在线播放 | 久久噜噜亚洲综合| av电影在线不卡| 亚洲成精国产精品女| 欧美一区二区免费视频| 岛国一区二区三区| 亚洲综合激情网| 欧美成人三级电影在线| 成人午夜视频免费看| 亚洲国产欧美在线人成| 久久欧美一区二区| 91九色02白丝porn| 男女激情视频一区| 国产精品区一区二区三| 欧美日韩三级在线| 国产高清精品久久久久| 亚洲国产精品久久久男人的天堂| 精品国产3级a| 色女孩综合影院| 国产综合久久久久影院| 樱桃国产成人精品视频| 欧美va亚洲va国产综合| 99久久精品99国产精品| 秋霞午夜鲁丝一区二区老狼| 日韩一区日韩二区| 日韩欧美一区中文| 99这里都是精品| 久久精品国产77777蜜臀| **欧美大码日韩| 欧美岛国在线观看| 色婷婷综合久久久久中文| 久久不见久久见免费视频1| 亚洲日本韩国一区| 精品久久免费看| 91官网在线免费观看| 国产一区二区0| 亚洲国产精品尤物yw在线观看| 国产日韩欧美制服另类| 欧美一区二区在线不卡| 91在线视频网址| 国模一区二区三区白浆| 亚洲一二三四久久| 国产视频911| 日韩午夜激情视频| 在线视频国内自拍亚洲视频| 国产激情偷乱视频一区二区三区| 日韩精品91亚洲二区在线观看 | 中文字幕av不卡| 欧美一区二区三区啪啪| 91黄色免费看| 国产成人综合网站| 麻豆成人久久精品二区三区小说| 一区二区成人在线| 中文字幕在线播放不卡一区| 亚洲精品一区二区三区蜜桃下载 | 欧美一区二区三区在线视频| 99热这里都是精品| 国产在线精品国自产拍免费| 亚洲a一区二区| 亚洲人成网站色在线观看| 国产日韩欧美a| 精品成a人在线观看| 欧美一区二区播放| 欧美色电影在线| 91色视频在线| 国产成人a级片| 精品一区中文字幕| 免费黄网站欧美| 一级中文字幕一区二区| 亚洲欧美视频在线观看视频| 欧美极品xxx| 久久久精品欧美丰满| 精品国产乱码91久久久久久网站| 欧美精选一区二区| 欧美调教femdomvk| 欧美性大战久久久久久久蜜臀 | 91精品国产综合久久福利| 欧美色涩在线第一页| 在线欧美日韩国产| 91小视频在线观看| 波多野结衣亚洲| eeuss影院一区二区三区| 国产suv一区二区三区88区| 国产一区二区91| 国产精品一区不卡| 国产成人在线影院| 国产传媒久久文化传媒| 国产精品自拍毛片| 国产精品一区一区| 欧美日韩精品一区二区三区 | 成人自拍视频在线观看| 国产一区二区三区久久悠悠色av| 九九热在线视频观看这里只有精品| 日韩激情中文字幕| 三级影片在线观看欧美日韩一区二区| 亚洲一卡二卡三卡四卡| 亚洲五码中文字幕| 亚洲国产欧美日韩另类综合| 亚洲电影一区二区三区| 亚洲午夜免费视频| 日日噜噜夜夜狠狠视频欧美人| 亚洲国产精品久久不卡毛片| 性做久久久久久免费观看| 日韩国产精品久久久久久亚洲| 日本成人在线不卡视频| 麻豆一区二区在线| 国产精品一级二级三级| 国产不卡视频在线播放| aaa国产一区| 欧美手机在线视频| 91精品福利在线一区二区三区 | 亚洲h精品动漫在线观看| 日韩黄色在线观看| 看片网站欧美日韩| 国产激情精品久久久第一区二区| 成人一区二区三区中文字幕| 91丨九色丨蝌蚪富婆spa| 欧美午夜免费电影| 制服丝袜国产精品| 久久婷婷色综合| 国产精品第一页第二页第三页| 亚洲精品写真福利| 日韩精品欧美成人高清一区二区| 精品伊人久久久久7777人| 丁香六月久久综合狠狠色| 色婷婷久久综合| 欧美日韩成人激情| 精品国产凹凸成av人网站| 中国av一区二区三区| 亚洲激情在线激情| 奇米色777欧美一区二区| 国产精品一级片在线观看| 99精品国产视频| 这里只有精品视频在线观看| 久久品道一品道久久精品| 亚洲欧美另类小说| 免费成人性网站| 北条麻妃国产九九精品视频| 欧美精品一卡二卡| 国产视频一区二区在线| 一区二区三区 在线观看视频| 蜜桃av一区二区在线观看| 国产成人精品aa毛片| 欧美色图一区二区三区| 久久蜜桃av一区二区天堂| 亚洲精品国产无套在线观| 久久成人羞羞网站| 91丨九色丨黑人外教| 91精品国产综合久久福利| 国产精品理论在线观看| 五月激情综合网| 成人午夜av电影| 777久久久精品| 国产精品美女久久久久久| 水野朝阳av一区二区三区| 国产91丝袜在线观看| 在线播放日韩导航| 国产精品入口麻豆原神| 日韩高清不卡一区| 成人av电影在线网| 日韩午夜精品视频| 亚洲免费av观看| 国产乱国产乱300精品| 欧美日韩专区在线| 国产精品久久久久7777按摩| 日本一区中文字幕| 色诱视频网站一区| 国产清纯在线一区二区www| 天堂av在线一区| 成人黄色一级视频| 精品国产乱码久久久久久图片| 一区二区三区日韩欧美| 国产91精品精华液一区二区三区| 337p亚洲精品色噜噜狠狠| 亚洲欧美日韩电影| 国产成人在线网站| 日韩色在线观看| 亚洲国产精品精华液网站| 99久久婷婷国产综合精品| 久久婷婷国产综合精品青草| 天堂av在线一区| 欧美在线综合视频| 中文字幕日本乱码精品影院| 国产精品亚洲综合一区在线观看| 欧美一区二区精品久久911| 一区二区不卡在线播放| 99综合影院在线| 久久久一区二区三区| 麻豆国产精品官网| 欧美剧情片在线观看| 亚洲激情男女视频|