Apps for baby faulted over claims of educational benefits

    Updated: 2013-08-18 07:51

    By Natasha Singer(The New York Times)

      Print Mail Large Medium  Small

    The Walt Disney Company's "Baby Einstein" videos do not turn babies into prodigies. And despite marketing claims by Fisher-Price, its popular "Laugh & Learn" mobile apps may not teach babies language or counting skills, according to a complaint filed with the United States Federal Trade Commission.

    The complaint to the commission by the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood, the same nonprofit group that helped prompt "Baby Einstein" to backtrack from its educational claims, challenges the idea that learning apps provide more than simple entertainment value.

    In addition to the complaint against Fisher-Price "Laugh & Learn" apps, which have been downloaded more than 2.8 million times, the advocacy group filed a similar complaint against apps for babies marketed by Open Solutions.

    According to the complaints, the companies say in marketing material that their apps teach infants spatial skills, numbers, language or motor skills. But, the complaints claim, there is no rigorous scientific evidence to prove that these kinds of products provide those benefits.

    "The baby genius industry is notorious for marketing products as educational, when in fact there is no evidence that they are," said Susan Linn, the director of the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood, in Boston.

    The group contends that using such apps "may be detrimental to very young children." Ms. Linn said the programs could take time away from activities, like hands-on creative play or face-time with caring adults. She said the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends parents avoid screen media for children under 2.

    Kathleen Alfano, the senior director of child research at Fisher-Price, said the company conducts extensive research "to create appropriate toys for the ways children play, discover and grow."

    Apps for baby faulted over claims of educational benefits

    Stefan Babinec, an executive at Open Solutions, based in Bratislava, Slovakia, said his company's marketing does not make claims like "get this game and let it teach your child everything." Rather, he said, the company thinks its apps "can help parents with babies, either by entertaining babies or help them see new things, animals, hear their sounds, etc."

    The Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood pointed to seven apps marketed by Fisher-Price, along with eight by Open Solutions, which have been available on the Apple App or iTunes stores. The apps feature animated or high-definition illustrations of animal characters that invite younger children to listen to phrases or animal noises or point to the animals' body parts. The apps are marketed as having educational value for very young children.

    The information page for a Fisher-Price iPad app called Laugh & Learn Let's Count Animals for Baby, for instance, says the app "teaches numbers and counting, 1-10, animals, first words and action/reaction."

    Russ Crupnick, senior vice president for industry analysis at the NPD Group, a market research firm, said that parents who had downloaded such apps often felt that the technology had made learning more entertaining and easier for their children. "A lot of parents think these apps are very educational," he said.

    In 2011, the consumer group filed a complaint against the marketers of a video product, "Your Baby Can Read." Ads for the videos suggested they could teach infants as young as 9 months old to read. Last year, the company, called Your Baby Can, agreed to settle trade commission charges of false advertising.

    Now app developers are marketing the same kinds of baby learning programs in mobile formats, Ms. Linn said, with the potential to increase the amount of time that infants spend in front of screens and affect their brain development. "This is one of our main concerns and why we take this industry on," Ms. Linn said.

    The New York Times

    (China Daily 08/18/2013 page11)

    日本乱中文字幕系列观看| 狠狠躁天天躁无码中文字幕| 精品人无码一区二区三区| www日韩中文字幕在线看| 无码 免费 国产在线观看91| 日木av无码专区亚洲av毛片| 天堂中文8资源在线8| 无码人妻精品中文字幕免费东京热| 亚洲va无码手机在线电影| 亚洲七七久久精品中文国产| 下载天堂国产AV成人无码精品网站| 无码精品A∨在线观看中文| 中文字幕在线无码一区二区三区| a中文字幕1区| 亚洲中文字幕无码专区| 精品久久久久久久无码| 人妻中文字幕无码专区| 最新无码A∨在线观看| 亚洲一区日韩高清中文字幕亚洲 | 亚洲国产一二三精品无码| 在线综合+亚洲+欧美中文字幕| 国产 日韩 中文字幕 制服| 久久久无码精品午夜| 成人无码精品1区2区3区免费看| 国产成人无码区免费内射一片色欲| 狠狠综合久久综合中文88| 人妻精品久久久久中文字幕一冢本 | 久久精品无码一区二区三区日韩| 无码AV中文一区二区三区| 亚洲国产精品无码成人片久久| 高清无码中文字幕在线观看视频| 日本精品中文字幕| 最近中文字幕大全免费视频 | 亚洲欧美日韩另类中文字幕组| 国产在线精品一区二区中文| 亚洲精品乱码久久久久久中文字幕 | 无码人妻少妇久久中文字幕| 久久精品99无色码中文字幕| 亚洲日韩在线中文字幕综合| 亚洲精品无码久久久久去q | 911国产免费无码专区|