Global EditionASIA 中文雙語Fran?ais
    China
    Home / China / Society

    Beijing court prepares ground for hearings in cyberspace

    By Cao Yin | China Daily | Updated: 2018-02-01 09:48
    Share
    Share - WeChat

    Technological developments could signal profound changes for the nation's judicial system, as Cao Yin reports.

    LIANG LUWEN/FOR CHINA DAILY

    Over the years, Wang Yangwei has often had to spend an entire day waiting at Beijing Haidian District People's Court to file a single case.

    However, one day in December, the lawyer stayed in his office and filed more than 10 lawsuits in just one hour.

    "The quicker process is due to the court's WeChat platform. I was surprised to be notified the very next day that every case had been accepted. It was amazingly efficient," he said.

    "I use WeChat every day, but I never thought I would be able to use it to file cases."

    The court opened the platform on Dec 25, and so far 84 cases, mostly civil, commercial or related to verdict enforcements, have been filed through it. On Jan 19, the platform was extended to all the courts in the capital.

    The new system saves time for both judges and litigants, according to Zhang Zhifu, deputy chief judge of the court's case-filing department.

    "Filing a case via a smartphone is just the first step; the ability to hear cases on WeChat is also on the horizon," he added.

    The platform has also impressed Wu Fei, creator of Faxiansheng, or "Mr Law", a smartphone app that provides supplementary legal materials such as interpretations of rulings and explanations of various laws.

    "The era of mobile or handheld courts is approaching," he said, adding that the WeChat platform is a pointer to things to come.

    Wu said he is optimistic about the possibility of conducting trials in Beijing via smartphone app, and cited the rising number of legal procedures, including case filing, being put online. He noted that China's first internet court, which provides a limited service in Hangzhou, Zhejiang province, is exploring new ways of providing legal assistance via social media and the internet.

    However, some legal professionals have expressed concerns about the justice system's growing use of apps and online facilities.

    "We need to conduct more studies to identify the types of cases suitable to be heard on WeChat and how we could maintain order during online trials," said Cheng Hu, vice-president of Beijing No 4 Intermediate People's Court.

    He added that issues such as ensuring due respect for the court and public oversight of tribunals via social media should be also taken into consideration.

    Convenience

    According to Wang, using WeChat to submit case materials to courts and pay legal fees has liberated him from his old routine.

    "The case-filing platform on WeChat leaves me more time to do other work, and I don't have to worry about traffic jams or long periods spent waiting at the court," he said.

    Zhang said the new platform not only benefits litigants and lawyers, but also improves judges' efficiency.

    "They can review materials and file cases while riding in an elevator or on the way to meetings," he said.

    He estimated that by the end of the year, more than 40 percent of the cases at his court will be filed via WeChat.

    "It's an innovation in justice," he said. "If technologies, such as facial recognition, can be developed and updated quickly and efficiently enough, we will see more calls for cases to be conducted via smartphones."

    More than 3,000 kilometers from Beijing, a court in Urumqi, Xingjiang Uygur autonomous region, has occasionally experimented with hearing cases via WeChat during the past two years.

    In March 2016, the court spent nearly 50 minutes hearing a case on WeChat in which the main defendant was in Shanghai.

    Both parties provided their evidence and case materials, and the dispute was finally concluded via mediation.

    Doubts

    Despite developments, some observers have expressed doubts that proceedings could be conducted effectively online or via social media.

    "Having a hearing on a smartphone seems efficient, but I would hesitate to conduct a case that way," Wang, the lawyer in Beijing, said.

    "When I provide case materials on WeChat, I trust the court because I know it is reliable and it will protect the information, but the courts will need to find ways of confirming litigants' identities, for example, to ensure they are who they claim to be," he added.

    "Also, what would happen if someone involved in a case suddenly quits during a WeChat trial?"

    Cheng, from Beijing No 4 Intermediate People's Court, voiced similar concerns.

    His court uses WeChat's video system to hear cases brought against government departments in Tianjin relating to breaches of environmental laws.

    However, litigants must also attend a court in the northern port city to discuss matters with a judge.

    Cheng stressed that the use of technology should not affect the status of courts.

    "In all cases, we should uphold the dignity and seriousness of trials. So hearing cases on WeChat would pose problems and we would need to conduct research to solve them," he said.

    Greater transparency

    Liu Junhai, a professor of law at Renmin University of China, said the move would be a natural development and would benefit the evolution of tech-friendly courts.

    But according to Gu Yongzhong, a law professor at the China University of Political Science and Law, it would be hard to ensure public supervision and attendance if cases were heard on WeChat because, like other instant-messaging tools, it is primarily a closed platform.

    However, Zhang from the court in Haidian, said WeChat conversations could be opened to the wider public.

    "When they use the platform, judges have easier access to case materials because the details and evidence provided on it are recorded. Also, if the technology were to be improved, netizens would be able to watch proceedings and comment on our performance, which would make our work more transparent," he said.

    He conceded that not all cases could be heard on social media.

    For example, he pointed out that judges hearing divorce cases must be able to assess people's facial expressions, attitudes and manner of speaking to help determine the accuracy of their evidence.

    Zhang Qinyuan, a judge at Beijing No 4 Intermediate Court, said: "Filing and hearing cases on WeChat would just be one option for solving disputes. It would all depend on the type of case we were dealing with, and we could not breach procedural laws to accommodate certain cases."

    Regulation required

    Wu, creator of "Mr Law", said unified standards and guidelines must be formulated to regulate the provision of legal services online.

    "Many courts are undertaking this work on their own-and that should be encouraged-but it's time to issue a national standard otherwise the process may become disorganized," he said.

    "After all, problems such as how to provide written judgments online and the types of cases that can be heard on WeChat are constantly emerging, and we urgently need to solve them."

    Top
    BACK TO THE TOP
    English
    Copyright 1995 - . All rights reserved. The content (including but not limited to text, photo, multimedia information, etc) published in this site belongs to China Daily Information Co (CDIC). Without written authorization from CDIC, such content shall not be republished or used in any form. Note: Browsers with 1024*768 or higher resolution are suggested for this site.
    License for publishing multimedia online 0108263

    Registration Number: 130349
    FOLLOW US
     
    无码AV片在线观看免费| 亚洲成人中文字幕| 国产AV无码专区亚洲AV手机麻豆 | 日韩专区无码人妻| 超清无码熟妇人妻AV在线电影| 久别的草原在线影院电影观看中文 | 亚洲毛片av日韩av无码| 无码区国产区在线播放| 中文字幕精品无码久久久久久3D日动漫 | 人妻中文无码久热丝袜| 午夜无码国产理论在线| 无码人妻精品中文字幕免费| 少妇性饥渴无码A区免费 | 中文字幕无码成人免费视频| 黄桃AV无码免费一区二区三区| 日日摸夜夜爽无码毛片精选| 免费无码国产在线观国内自拍中文字幕 | 日韩精品人妻一区二区中文八零| 潮喷无码正在播放| 亚洲AV人无码激艳猛片| 中文无码久久精品| 成人A片产无码免费视频在线观看| 中文字幕久久亚洲一区| 日本一区二区三区中文字幕| 中文字幕亚洲精品资源网| 爆操夜夜操天天操狠操中文| 亚洲日本va中文字幕久久| 中文字幕一精品亚洲无线一区| 亚洲精品一级无码鲁丝片| 宅男在线国产精品无码| 久久中文字幕人妻丝袜| 亚洲一区二区三区在线观看精品中文 | 久久无码AV一区二区三区| 综合久久久久久中文字幕亚洲国产国产综合一区首 | 国产成人一区二区三中文| 国产∨亚洲V天堂无码久久久| 人妻无码久久一区二区三区免费| 十八禁无码免费网站| 国产乱子伦精品无码码专区| 亚洲综合无码一区二区| 无码精品人妻一区|