Editorials

    Academic prudence

    (China Daily)
    Updated: 2010-01-15 07:52
    Large Medium Small

    Top archeologists are confident that what was excavated in Anyang, Henan province, is the tomb of Cao Cao (155-220), warlord and penultimate chancellor of the Eastern Han Dynasty (AD 25-220).

    The discovery immediately made it to the list of the "Top Six" new archeological findings of 2009, compiled by the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences.

    The country's top archeologists, sent from the academy to verify the findings of another team of archaeologists in the province, said that they have more evidence to back up the assertion that the findings are of Cao Cao's tomb. But they have been modest so far, calling their judgment "prima facie".

    Related readings:
    Academic prudence Expert tries to clear controversy over Cao's tomb
    Academic prudence Cao's tomb among top discoveries of 2009
    Academic prudence Cao gets a makeover

    Their prudence was evident at Thursday's press conference, which was called a public forum to answer suspicions aired in past weeks. We even felt that the archeologists might have been overly precise about details of the excavations.

    But we appreciate the way the scholars handled the highly controversial topic. We believe such an approach is conducive not only to the intellectual world's constructive interaction with society, but also to enlightening our laymen in public.

    Were it not for the classic Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the average man would not have cared about Cao Cao. Had the book not been associated with the household name Cao Cao, few might care what the archeologists unearthed.

    Cao Cao helped build the strongest and most prosperous state during the Three Kingdoms period (AD 220-280) and was remembered for his outstanding military and political talents.

    But Cao Cao, the cursed and well-praised legendary general, left behind many myths, some about his burial site. It is therefore only natural that many may have formed their own opinions of the site.

    The most vociferous skeptics were outside the circle of experts. We heard cultural relic collectors and classic literature researchers discrediting the archeologists' assertions.

    And questions were not limited to the authenticity of evidence. On the Internet, suspicions of economic motivations abound - Cao Cao has been too famous to not draw curious visitors to his burial ground.

    We saw the scholars' discomfort with irresponsible lay comments. But given the universal drop in public confidence of public institutions, including everything previously considered as true, the questions were inevitable.

    We liked their scholarly manner. They have chosen to communicate instead of imposing their judgment upon their audience.

    That the archeologists have taken pains to explain the highly technical work to the public is admirable. They not only provided evidence, but also explained how the field work was conducted.

    And, instead of blaming ignorance on their critics, they put the criticism on their shoulders, claiming that they failed to provide information to the interested public.

    Besides, they left ample room for counter arguments and evidence: They said their conclusion is not final. That is the way intellectual work should be.

    Rather than whether or not we have truly found the remains of Cao Cao, we are more interested in seeing followers of such a wonderful example.

    (China Daily 01/15/2010 page8)

    中文精品一卡2卡3卡4卡| 少妇人妻偷人精品无码视频| 日韩乱码人妻无码系列中文字幕| 亚洲欧美综合在线中文| 亚洲av永久无码精品表情包| 亚洲Av无码乱码在线观看性色 | 无码国产色欲XXXXX视频| 日韩中文字幕在线观看| 无码国产亚洲日韩国精品视频一区二区三区 | 亚洲无码黄色网址| 人妻精品久久无码区| 久久久无码精品亚洲日韩蜜臀浪潮| 亚洲国产精品无码久久九九 | 国产亚洲精品无码专区| 无码精品人妻一区二区三区免费看| 一区 二区 三区 中文字幕| 精品久久久久久久久中文字幕| 久久久无码精品午夜| 91嫩草国产在线无码观看| 亚洲AV无码一区东京热| 无码成人精品区在线观看| 日韩欧美一区二区不卡中文| 日韩va中文字幕无码电影| 少妇极品熟妇人妻无码| 丰满岳乱妇在线观看中字无码| 日韩免费无码视频一区二区三区| 国产在线无码精品电影网| 最近高清中文在线字幕在线观看| 最近中文字幕mv免费高清在线| 日本精品久久久久中文字幕| 亚洲中文久久精品无码ww16| 中文无码人妻有码人妻中文字幕| 无码毛片一区二区三区中文字幕| 2021国产毛片无码视频| 亚洲AV永久无码天堂影院| 亚洲AV无码成人精品区狼人影院| 毛片一区二区三区无码| 亚洲中久无码不卡永久在线观看| 人妻少妇精品无码专区动漫| 无码免费又爽又高潮喷水的视频 | 亚洲精品高清无码视频|