Experts say Apple has trademark weakness

    Updated: 2012-02-20 07:31

    By Wang Huazhong and Cao Yin (China Daily)

      Comments() Print Mail Large Medium  Small 分享按鈕 0

    BEIJING - The names of iPhone and iPad could wind up on hiking shoes, veterinary drugs or even diapers in China if Apple fails to remedy flaws in its brand strategy, experts say.

    At least 39 Chinese companies and individuals in recent years have attempted to register the two trademarks in categories that Apple has not, according to the China Trademark Website.

    Six, including a flashlight manufacturer, have gone so far as gaining preliminary approval from authorities and were forced to defend their applications when objections were raised in the final disclosure procedure, according to the website, run by the trademark office of the State Administration for Industry and Commerce.

    "Apple objected to our application on the last day of the three-month disclosure," said Xu Jie, a lawyer representing flashlight manufacturer Cai Zhiyong.

    Xu said the trademark office sent a letter to Cai on Feb 15, asking Cai to provide supporting evidence within a month.

    "We received the authorities' go-ahead to move into the disclosure stage, and we are confident we will be successful," Xu said.

    Xu said it took him by surprise when he, at the request of Cai, found Apple had not registered the trademarks in all of China's 45 commercial categories, a practice that other transnational companies follow.

    "Yes, we want to share the benefits of iPhone's fame through the application in 2010," Xu told China Daily.

    Beside the flashlight company based in Yiwu, East China's Zhejiang province, other companies from the Chinese mainland as well as Hong Kong and Taiwan also attempted to cash in on the success of Apple's products.

    According to the website, at least 18 entities attempted to apply for an iPad trademark after 2010, when popularity of the tablet computer exploded.

    A leather factory in Wenzhou, Zhejiang, specializing in belts and hiking shoes and another garment factory in East China's Jiangsu province applied to register the iPhone trademark, respectively, in 2007 and 2010. Their applications are also pending and remain in disputed status.

    There are other applications for the iPad trademark that have passed preliminary approval and now hang in bureaucratic limbo as Apple disputes their claim, such as one by Guangdong glass lens manufacturer Ye Huochai and another by a Guangdong company that makes floorboards and concrete.

    None of the applicants have successfully obtained the trademarks so far, according to the website.

    To date, Apple has registered the iPad in nine categories and the iPhone in 14 categories, according to the website.

    Later this month, courts in China will hear an iPad trademark dispute between Apple and an insolvent Shenzhen-based company called Proview.

    A law enforcer with the Beijing administration of industry and commerce, who declined to give her name, told China Daily the attempts to take advantage of famous names are "immoral but legally permissible".

    She said many international companies have a system for monitoring their trademark properties and Apple "seems to not have managed risks well to protect itself".

    Feng Xiaoqing, a professor who studies intellectual property rights, said flaws exist in the implementation of Apple's brand strategy that result in disputes. Feng said many Chinese companies face the same situation overseas as well.

    He said Apple can seek protection from the Chinese Law of Trademarks that prevents "famous" ones from being registered under other categories.

    "Even if the iPhone has not gained certified status as 'famous brand' in China, the law can grant special protection to well-known brands on condition that the same brand in other categories might mislead and confuse the public."

    Gu Jun, a professor in sociology at Shanghai University, does not think Apple's predicament is due to its negligence.

    "Apple is a big company with legal offices and has enjoyed a good reputation across the world. So it cannot simply ignore Chinese regulations."

    亚洲国产人成中文幕一级二级| 无码少妇一区二区三区| 高潮潮喷奶水飞溅视频无码| 成人无码区免费A∨直播| 中文字幕乱偷无码AV先锋| 无码人妻黑人中文字幕| 最近最新高清免费中文字幕| 国产又爽又黄无码无遮挡在线观看| 特级做A爰片毛片免费看无码| 中文字幕在线亚洲精品| HEYZO无码综合国产精品227| 中文一国产一无码一日韩| 中文字幕一区二区人妻性色| 日韩精品专区AV无码| 日韩中文久久| 91中文字幕在线观看| 无码av中文一二三区| 无码国产精成人午夜视频一区二区 | 人妻无码第一区二区三区| 国产精品99久久久精品无码| 中文字幕精品无码一区二区三区| 国产AV无码专区亚洲AV毛网站| 一本色道无码不卡在线观看 | 在线亚洲欧美中文精品| 亚洲中文字幕无码一区| 毛片免费全部无码播放| 国产在线精品无码二区| 十八禁无码免费网站| 亚洲AV无码成人精品区蜜桃 | 亚洲AV无码国产在丝袜线观看| 中文字幕乱码人妻综合二区三区| 天堂а√中文在线| 亚洲日本va中文字幕久久| 日韩精品人妻一区二区中文八零| 少妇无码太爽了不卡视频在线看| yy111111少妇无码影院| 欧洲人妻丰满av无码久久不卡| 色综合久久无码中文字幕| 久久精品国产亚洲AV无码娇色| 人妻丰满AV无码久久不卡| 免费A级毛片无码A∨|